A grieving daughter is campaigning for a new law requiring mandatory second opinions on benign cancer diagnoses within the NHS, following the misdiagnosis and subsequent death of her mother.
Chloe Hickman, 24, from Ipswich, launched a Change.org petition urging the government to implement "Louise’s Law," named after her mother, Louise Hickman.
Louise Hickman tragically passed away in June 2023 from ovarian cancer, five years after doctors at Ipswich Hospital initially deemed her tumour benign. Chloe Hickman believes that if her mother’s cancer had been correctly diagnosed as malignant in 2019, she might still be alive today.
Currently, NHS guidelines afford patients the right to seek a second opinion, but this is not a legal requirement, according to The Patients Association, a charity advocating for improvements in health and social care. Louise’s Law would make it mandatory for benign test results to be reviewed by a specialist, potentially preventing future tragedies like the one experienced by the Hickman family. The petition highlights the devastating consequences of misdiagnosis and aims to strengthen patient safety within the NHS.
“She could have been offered chemotherapy, the surgery could have been brought forward, and she might still be here,” Miss Hickman told the PA news agency.
“That’s a horrible thought to navigate, and I can’t even begin to start with where my head goes, but if something like that were mandatory. It could save so many lives.”
She hopes the new legislation will not only help others who have been misdiagnosed but also help to honour her mother’s life.
“Losing my mum at such a young age, I now have to navigate life without my mum, and your mum is typically someone who helps keep you safe and shelters you from the world,” she said.
“If that law is in place, not only is that saving countless lives… but also that could be a way of my mum saving me in the future.
“She’s still looking after me and keeping me safe because (Louise’s Law) is in place.”
Miss Hickman described her mother as a “very strong, independent” person, but quickly lost her sense of autonomy after she found a cyst in January 2019, which doctors diagnosed as a mature cystic teratoma, a common non-cancerous tumour found in the ovaries.
In April 2022, she was diagnosed with ovarian cancer and underwent chemotherapy and surgery to remove two fluid-filled sacs weighing 11 and 19 litres each.
She was in remission for around six months before relapsing in March last year, and Miss Hickman said doctors advised her mother that the cancer diagnosis was not linked to the initial diagnosis in 2019.
“The reason it had recurred is because this cancer was linked to the 2019 specimen that was malignant at the time,” Miss Hickman explained.
“When she was ill, a lot of her independence was taken away, and that’s quite hard to navigate. It affects your outlook on life, but it also makes you feel a little bit vulnerable.”
The 24-year-old believes there is a lack of support for people who experience misdiagnoses prompting her to create Louise’s Law.
“I hear about a lot of things with the NHS, like staffing issues and wait times, but married with that, you actively see things being put in place or trying to be put in place to solve that,” she said.
“I never hear about anything for misdiagnoses. It just seems to be a fact of life, and it shouldn’t be like that.”
Miss Hickman said support for her petition “spiralled so quickly” and it has received more than 40,000 signatures so far.
She feels it is her “duty” to fight for people with benign scans and make it mandatory to receive a second opinion from doctors.
“Nothing will change the people we’ve lost if this law gets passed but it will give a sense of hope for the future, not necessarily for the individuals that it’s already affected, but for people moving forward,” she said.
“I’d like to know when enough is enough, and what bottom do we have to hit before someone looks at this situation for what it is.”
Dr Tim Leary, interim chief medical officer at East Suffolk and North Essex NHS Foundation Trust, which runs Ipswich Hospital expressed his “deepest sympathies” to Miss Hickman and her family.
“We launched a patient safety investigation following the delay of her cancer diagnosis. We have met with her family and shared the outcome of that investigation,” he said.
“We understand they still have some concerns and questions. We are listening and our teams will continue to support them further at this very difficult time.
“The lessons learned from Louise’s care and treatment will be used to improve our processes and services.”
To find out more about Miss Hickman’s petition, click here.
New 1,500-place prison opens amid bid to tackle jail overcrowding
Ninja sword ban under Ronan’s Law set to come into force by summer
Bid to reverse postponement of local elections defeated in the Lords
‘I track my mum, 86, with an AI monitor so she doesn’t have to move into care’
Morning-after pill to be given out free at pharmacies
Texas measles outbreak spikes as experts warn US should take action
