It goes without saying that the idea of people staying with a single employer for their entire working lives, and receiving an engraved gold watch and a pension upon retirement, is out of date.
According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), the youngest Baby Boomers, born between 1957 and 1964, held 12.7 jobs on average from ages 18 to 56.
Furthermore, the BLS found that, in January 2022, the median number of years that paid employees had been with their present employer was 4.1 years.
In today’s highly mobile workforce, consumers need to keep on top of their hard-earned retirement savings. If they’re not careful, they can lose track of their 401(k) savings in their prior employers’ plans when they switch jobs.
Historically, it has not been easy, to put it mildly, for Americans to take their 401(k) balances with them when they leave one employer for another. Without assistance from employers and their plan recordkeepers, the process can take months, costing a lot of time and money. Too often, Americans find it easier to leave their 401(k) accounts behind in their previous employers’ plans, or prematurely cash out their 401(k) accounts, after they depart.
Neither of these options are conducive to helping Americans save for a financially secure retirement.
Why you shouldn’t cash out
According to the Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI), the retirement services industry’s gold-standard research provider, Americans cash out their 401(k)s after leaving or changing jobs to the tune of $92 billion per year — and pay taxes and penalties on what they cash out.
In addition to paying taxes and penalties on the 401(k) savings they cash out from their previous employers’ plans, those who cash out also forfeit what their 401(k) accounts could have earned if they had remained incubated and invested in the national 401(k) system.
Our own research indicates that a plan participant who chooses to preserve a $7,000 401(k) balance at age 25, instead of cashing it out, would see that amount grow to $86,912 that they can use for income in retirement. Furthermore:
- Preserving a $7,000 401(k) balance at age 25 and another $7,000 balance at age 35 would provide $133,213 in retirement income.
- Preserving $7,000 401(k) accounts at ages 25, 35 and 45, as they go along their journeys toward retirement, would cause those balances to grow to $157,878 in total.
Cashing out can make a big dent in an American’s retirement prospects. The Center for Retirement Research at Boston College found in one of its studies that premature 401(k) account withdrawals can decrease Americans’ income in retirement by an average of 25%.
Why you shouldn’t leave behind your 401(k) savings
Preserving 401(k) savings instead of cashing out when leaving and/or switching jobs is far better than cashing out, but letting 401(k) accounts sit in prior-employer plans isn’t the best course of action either.
Under the Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001, 401(k) plan sponsors were given the authority to automatically roll small accounts from terminated employees with up to $5,000 into investment vehicles known as safe-harbor IRAs. That same law made principal-protected products — which haven’t yielded significant returns due to low interest rates following the 2008 financial crisis — the only default investment options permitted in safe-harbor IRAs. In addition, many safe-harbor IRAs charge as much as $50 or more in annual administration fees, according to publicly available information.
In other words, leaving behind a 401(k) account in a former employer’s plan, and not taking action to consolidate your savings, can lead to account depletion over the long term.
And the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022 raised the mandatory distribution limit on small accounts that plan sponsors can automatically roll out of their plans and into safe-harbor IRAs from $5,000 to $7,000, as of December 31, 2023.
This means many more job-changing Americans are at risk of having their stranded accounts in former-employer plans automatically moved into safe-harbor IRAs. In fact, EBRI estimates that throughout this year, 6.7 million Americans who participate in 401(k) plans will switch jobs — and on a one-time basis beginning this year, an additional 1.1 million Americans who left behind small balances in their former employers’ 401(k) plans could immediately become eligible to have their savings wind up in safe-harbor IRAs.
What should you do?
Instead of cashing out or leaving 401(k)s behind, hardworking Americans who switch jobs now have a much better chance of receiving meaningful assistance with taking their 401(k) savings with them to their new employers — and consolidating them in the active accounts in their new employers’ plans.
The Portability Services Network’s digital auto portability solution, which automates the process of moving 401(k) account balances with under $7,000 from plan to plan, went live in November. (I am the CEO of Portability Services Network.) This retirement services industry utility includes, as founding members, some of the largest 401(k) plan recordkeepers.
If the recordkeeper for an employee’s new and/or former employers’ plans are part of the Portability Services Network, consumers can reach out for assistance with 401(k) asset transportation and consolidation.
Don’t let your 401(k) savings be depleted when you switch jobs. Take your 401(k) savings with you from job to job, at every point along your journey to retirement — and optimize your income.
