Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Manchester Evening News
Manchester Evening News
Entertainment
Emma Gill

We tried chocolate cake from Asda, Morrisons, Sainsbury's, Tesco, Aldi and Lidl and the cheapest came out top

There aren't many people who'd turn down a piece of chocolate cake are there, well not in my family anyway.

So when given the task of taste testing the dessert from each of the main supermarkets, a gathering for my nephew's birthday - he's biggest cake fan of us all - seemed the ideal place to do it.

He thought all his birthdays had come at once when Auntie Emma arrived with offerings from Asda, Morrisons, Sainsbury's, Tesco, Aldi and Lidl.

Read more: Experts share six foods you should eat to keep warm without the central heating - and which to avoid

We tried chocolate cake from Asda, Morrisons, Sainsbury's, Tesco, Aldi and Lidl (Manchester Family / MEN)

But how do they compare?

Appearance

From chocolate fudge cake to finest chocolate cake, they may have different names, but effectively it's the same thing.

They all have a Belgian chocolate buttercream top, but the most obvious difference is the decoration.

The majority are adorned with white and milk chocolate curls, Morrisons and Aldi getting brownie points for the most, yet these are absent from the Lidl and Sainsbury's cakes - making them a little less appealing for the true chocoholics.

They all have a chocolate buttercream filling though, which adds to the taste and stops any of them seeming too dry.

There's no added decoration on the cakes from Sainsbury's or Lidl (Manchester Family / MEN)

Size

As with our previous carrot cake taste test, you wouldn't notice any difference from looking at them. Each one says serve six and they do, but you're not getting a particularly big slice.

There is a slight weight difference, ranging from around 380g to little over 400g, but it's not really noticeable.

Texture and taste

It's a tricky task tasting all that chocolate cake in one sitting, but between 13 of us we managed it - cutting off a small slice of each one to compare.

We started off with the budget brands of Aldi and Lidl, thinking perhaps the quality and taste would improve as we made our way onto the main supermarket offerings.

The Tesco cake was a little on the dry side (Manchester Family / MEN)

Yet it turned out that when it comes to chocolate cake, the well known proverb 'you get what you pay for' simply doesn't apply.

Asda's was generally a bit tasteless, Tesco's a bit on the dry side with little fondness for its chocolate and Sainsbury's, well, a nice sponge - and in fact the birthday boy's favourite - but most of us felt it suffered from the lack of added decoration and subsequent flavour.

Morrisons' was a little too moist with what seemed like an alcohol aftertaste and while Lidl's was preferred by one of us, the majority felt its lighter sponge was just a bit too bland.

So you've probably guessed by now that it was Aldi that was the clear winner - with 11 of us all picking it as our standout favourite. Who knew a family could be in such agreement?

Aldi was the clear winner (Manchester Family / MEN)

None of us are Mary Berry here, but we do like cake and have eaten copious amounts between us over the years, so I'd like to think our opinion counts for something.

Price

There are regular offers on these kind of products but usual prices are:

  • Sainsbury's £3
  • Tesco £2.90 (currently £2.15 Clubcard)
  • Morrisons £2.75
  • Asda £2.65 (current offer £2)
  • Lidl £2.19
  • Aldi £2.19
The Aldi cake is also joint cheapest with Lidl (Manchester Family / MEN)

So Asda and Tesco currently have theirs on offer with various promotions, but the standard price of the winning cake from Aldi, £2.19, is the joint cheapest alongside Lidl. It seems that other well known proverb 'you can have your cake and eat it' does apply.

Read more of today's top stories here

READ NEXT:

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.