Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
ABC News
ABC News
National

WA industry to consider 'legal avenues' if federal government's live sheep export ban goes ahead

Western Australia accounts for nearly all of Australia's live sheep exports. (ABC News: Hugh Sando)

Legal action may be considered in response to any federal ban on live sheep exports, Western Australian stakeholders have warned, pointing to the successful class action against the previous Labor government's live cattle export ban in 2011.

Live sheep exports, which are worth an estimated $92 million to the Australian economy, are set to be wound down on the advice of a newly appointed panel, which will undertake a six-month consultation process and how it may happen.

But Pilbara feedlot owner Paul Brown, who served one term as a Nationals MP in WA's Legislative Council, was angered that the panel's mandate appeared to indicate a ban was a foregone conclusion.

Mr Brown said the live sheep industry could contemplate action similar to that launched in response to federal Labor's 2011 ban on live cattle exports to Indonesia.

"I'm sure they'll be looking at what legal avenues they'll be able to take," he said.

He believed the government's position was the "thin edge of the wedge" for Australia's live export industries.

"When it comes to policy, it's all about the social licence," Mr Brown said.

"And eventually the inner-city votes will determine live export of cattle has a diminishing social license, and they'll come knocking at our door in the live cattle industry as well."

Hedland Export Depot owner Paul Brown says sheep producers may use legal avenues to fight any ban. (ABC News: Rebecca Parish)

With his business also providing services to sheep producers in WA's south, Mr Brown said he and his staff felt particularly exposed.

"It concerns me that myself and my staff are facing an uncertain future," he said.

"It's a business that's being operating for the better part of 20 years."

A matter for producers

Federal Agriculture Minister Murray Watt said it was up to sheep producers to decide whether they worked with the federal government to end live sheep exports, or opt for a legal fight.

"I'm confident we can come to an arrangement with industry, with the many thousands of people around Australia who care about animal welfare, that delivers on this commitment and treats people fairly," Senator Watt told WA Country Hour's Belinda Varischetti.

WA sheep producers account for the vast majority of the live export trade, with almost all being sent from WA ports.

But Senator Watt said live export only involved 12 per cent of sheep produced in WA.

"For those 12 per cent, we do want to make sure we come up with a good plan for the future," he said.

"That may well involve onshore processing, which means more jobs for Australians."

Senator Watt says there are significant opportunities for WA sheep producers outside of live export. (Supplied: NTLEA)

Mr Watt said the government had been working hard to open up new markets for boxed sheep meat, including in the United Kingdom, India and potentially the European Union.

"I'm confident we can come up with a plan that supports this industry," he said.

"Things will be different as a result of this, but I still think the industry has a very bright future in WA and across the country."

Establishing abattoirs 'incredibly difficult'

Sheep producer Robert Davy runs about 13,000 sheep on a property near Wellstead, 90 kilometres east of Albany on WA's south coast.

He said if the federal government was serious about phasing out live exports, it needed to invest heavily in local meat processing.

"Every town used to have an abattoir. Now there's only a handful," Mr Davy said.

"If they want this ban to go ahead, are they going to investment the millions needed to build abattoirs, and find the workers for them?"

Sheep producer Robert Davy says the government needs to invest heavily in onshore meat production. (ABC Great Southern: John Dobson)

He said getting an abattoir off the ground was "incredibly difficult" and could not "see that happening".

"These people, like Labor and welfare groups, are complaining about live export. Where's the investment going to come from?" Mr Davy said.

"If they're banning live sheep exports, they're not going to stop at sheep … the cattle industry will come under enormous pressure too.

"Farmers can't just plant trees and live off carbon credits."

Farmers say live export standards have improved. (Supplied: Rural Export and Trading WA)

WAFarmers Livestock Council member and wool grower Steve McGuire said sheep mortality rates had been decreasing and standards had improved due to the efforts of sheep producers and exporters.

"Who determines what social license is?" Mr McGuire said.

"Is it going to be determined by facts and science or is it going to be determined by feelings and emotions?

"That's no way to run a government."

Kuwaiti importer flags visit

With Kuwait the largest market for WA live sheep, Kuwait Live Livestock Transport and Trading (KLTT) chief executive Osama Boodai was already planning to visit Australia in May.

Rural Export and Trading WA general manager Murray Frangs worked closely with the state-owned importer and said he expected Mr Boodai would use the trip to address the potential threat to Kuwait's food security.

Kuwait, via ships such as the Al Kuwait (pictured), remains the largest market for WA live sheep. (ABC Rural: Tom Major)

"Hundreds of millions of dollars have been spent by KLTT and trading partners to invest in infrastructure and facilities throughout Australia … to maintain the capacity to import live sheep as it has done for over 50 years," he said.

"Now these investments are put in jeopardy."

Labelling the government's stance "confronting" and "devastating", Mr Frangs said the ban would end years of cooperation to improve animal welfare.

"Whilst data and science validates our very existence, it is conveniently overlooked in favour of narrow political alliances and historical considerations," he said.

No word on compensation

The panel, comprising former RSPCA chief executive officer Heather Neill, retired Northern Territory Labor MP Warren Snowdon and WA agriculture figure Sue Middleton, will be chaired by former Murray-Darling Basin CEO Phil Glyde.

Mr Watt would not be drawn on whether the government would pay compensation to those negatively impacted by the changes.

"These are exactly the kind of things that need to be considered through this consultation process," he said.

"We can't come up with a cost until we work out exactly how it will happen.

"Already the discussions I've had this morning from industry, animal welfare groups, governments, [is] there's a lot of ideas about what we could be doing."

Additional reporting by Lauren Smith, John Dobson and Eliza Borrello.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.