Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Top News
Top News

Uncertainty Surrounds Prisoner Exchanges as Plane Crash Sparks Controversy

FILE -People hold posters reading "Return defenders of Mariupol", "Free Azov", and others, during a demonstration in central Kyiv, Ukraine, Sunday, Dec. 3, 2023. The demonstration organized by the gro

In the midst of the ongoing tensions between Russia and Ukraine, one thing is abundantly clear: the fears, concerns, and uncertainties of families whose loved ones are held captive. The recent crash of a Russian military transport plane, with conflicting accounts from both sides, has only intensified these anxieties and raised questions about the future of prisoner exchanges.

Accusations are flying back and forth between Russia and Ukraine regarding the incident. Russian officials claim that the plane was shot down by Kyiv and assert that 65 Ukrainian prisoners of war were onboard, en route to a prisoner swap. However, the Ukrainian side disputes these allegations, stating that they have no evidence of POWs being on the plane and suggesting that Russia is merely playing with their psyche. Nevertheless, it is confirmed that a planned exchange was scheduled to take place.

The lack of concrete evidence and the conflicting narratives have left families in a vulnerable state, grappling with the uncertainty of their loved ones' fate. For many Ukrainians, this adds to the distress they have already been experiencing, as they have gone for months without any contact from their imprisoned family members.

Illia, a 21-year-old former prisoner of war, stands in the forest close to the hospital where he undergoes treatment in Kyiv, Ukraine, Thursday, Jan. 25, 2024. After he was exchanged nearly one year ago, he went through rehabilitation, yet the echoes of ten months of captivity continue to linger in his daily life. Recently he has started suddenly losing weight and doctors cannot find the reason. He now weighs only 44 kilograms (97 pounds.). (AP Photo/Hanna Arhirova)
FILE -People hold posters reading "Return defenders of Mariupol", "Free Azov", and others, during a demonstration in central Kyiv, Ukraine, Sunday, Dec. 3, 2023. The demonstration organized by the group "Azovstal Families" demands for the release of servicemen from Mariupol still in Russian captivity. (AP Photo/Alex Babenko, File)
Yevheniia Synelnyk, whose brother has been in captivity for over a year and a half, stands in park in Kyiv, Ukraine, Thursday, Jan. 25, 2024. Synelnyk is also a representative of the Association of Azovstal Defenders' Families, which was created in June of 2022, shortly after around 2,500 Ukrainian servicemen surrendered to Russia on the orders of the Ukrainian president during the siege of the Azovstal steel mill in May. According to the association, around 1,500 people remain captive. (AP Photo/Hanna Arhirova)

Yevheniia Synelnyk, whose brother has been in captivity for over a year and a half, describes the emotional rollercoaster experienced by families. On the day of the incident, she cried and worried as conflicting reports emerged. The following day, exhaustion set in, and she expressed her weariness in a tired voice. Synelnyk is also a representative of the Association of Azovstal Defenders’ Families, formed in June 2022 after around 2,500 Ukrainian servicemen surrendered to Russia during the siege of the Azovstal steel mill. According to the association, approximately 1,500 fighters from the steel mill remain in captivity, along with thousands more from other battles.

The concerns and anxieties of relatives are further compounded by the stories shared by returning POWs who speak of torture and abuse endured during their captivity. The fear that future exchanges may be halted leaves families in a state of heightened distress. Previously, released soldiers often provided information about other captives to their families, serving as a lifeline of hope. However, for many, the last time they heard anything about their loved ones was a year ago.

Despite the uncertainty and despair, these families find strength in their unity and support for one another. They rally together, organizing protests and demonstrations, driven by the belief that as long as they keep the spotlight on the captive individuals, there is hope for their safe return.

One former POW, a 21-year-old who goes by the call sign Smurf, attends these rallies religiously, feeling that it is the least he can do for those who are still in captivity. He vividly remembers the day of his own release, having been included in an exchange list without prior knowledge. Blindfolded and transported by plane, he endured the harrowing journey to freedom. However, the effects of ten months of captivity continue to linger in his daily life, with unexplained weight loss becoming an additional burden.

Smurf fears that the recent incident and the subsequent back-and-forth accusations between Russia and Ukraine jeopardize the future of prisoner exchanges, shattering the endless hopes of those eagerly awaiting the safe return of their loved ones. The dream of every prisoner of war, the possibility of freedom hangs in the balance.

As tensions persist and families anxiously await updates and developments, the collective strength and unwavering support within the community of captive individuals' relatives remain their source of resilience. They continue to hope, rally, and advocate for the safe return of their loved ones, determined to keep their plight in the public eye until they are reunited once more.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.