Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
Entertainment
Miriam Gillinson

The Oyster Problem review – the struggle to save Flaubert from himself

Fizzing facts … Left to right: Giles Taylor as Turgenev, Bob Barrett as Flaubert, Norma Atallah as George Sand, Rosalind Lailey as Caroline Commanville and Peter Hannah as Zola in The Oyster Problem.
Fizzing facts … Left to right: Giles Taylor as Turgenev, Bob Barrett as Flaubert, Norma Atallah as George Sand, Rosalind Lailey as Caroline Commanville and Peter Hannah as Zola in The Oyster Problem. Photograph: Tristram Kenton/The Guardian

While researching his book, The Europeans, Orlando Figes fell for the famous writers that populated his expansive work on 19th-century Europe. Turgenev was at the heart of The Europeans, but Flaubert is the focus of Figes’ very first play. With the great French writer’s life and money draining away, Turgenev, Zola and George Sand run increasingly desperate circles round their stubbornly romantic (and oyster-loving) friend, doomed to die for his art. It’s a sort of dream dinner party setup – only a lot of it is true.

Bob Barrett as Flaubert in The Oyster Problem by Orlando Figes.
Bob Barrett as Flaubert in The Oyster Problem by Orlando Figes. Photograph: Tristram Kenton/The Guardian

Figes is known for the depth and vibrancy of his research, and those trademark strengths shine through in Philip Wilson’s measured production. As the four writers discuss life, love and literature, fascinating details emerge. We hear about the famous actor Sarah Bernhardt’s book, In the Clouds, narrated by a chair in a giant hot air balloon. As Flaubert’s friends burst into his modest apartment in Rouen, we discover the great writer lived seven floors up. And when Turgenev and Zola mournfully discuss Flaubert’s achingly inevitable funeral, they laugh as they remember the coffin hovering above the ground – too big to fit in the hole below.

Fizzing facts like these breathe life into what is otherwise a fairly dramatically stagnant piece. Figes based a lot of the dialogue on original letters and it often sounds just that little bit over-composed and contained. Big ideas are discussed in earnest but they don’t bring us any closer to the characters, all cleverly reflected in Isabella Van Braeckel’s mirror-lined and Manet-inspired set.

Bob Barrett’s Flaubert wears tatty but flamboyant clothes, the warm but quick-tempered eccentric uncle of the gang. Giles Taylor’s Turgenev is all sophistication and serene wisdom and Norma Atallah’s George Sand is pleasingly no-nonsense, if not a little thinly drawn. Flaubert’s painter niece Caroline Commanville (Rosalind Lailey) is intriguing but she’s only on the edges of this play. It’s down to young upstart Zola, played by a restless and sharp-edged Peter Hannah, to fire things up. Zola’s passionate defence of his pragmatic approach to writing – his need for money as well as legacy – is one of the few times the neatly crafted conversations crack around the edges and start to feel messy, spontaneous and real.

• The Oyster Problem is at the Jermyn Street theatre, London, until 4 March.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.