Front row
The Lions are stronger in certain areas than others and much hinges, in every sense, on Ireland’s front row. No one would quibble hugely if an all-Irish triumvirate of Andrew Porter, Dan Sheehan and Tadhg Furlong pack down for the first Test against the Wallabies in Brisbane on 19 July – but what if all three are not fully firing? The talented, athletic Sheehan is just back from a long-term layoff and injury forced Porter to withdraw from the last Lions tour to South Africa before the squad’s departure. The admirable Furlong, meanwhile, has already been hammering away on Test rugby’s frontline for a decade. It underlines the importance of strength in depth, with the Australia scrum much improved. Both Scotland props, Pierre Schoeman and Zander Fagerson, will fancy making the plane, as will the Wales hooker Dewi Lake (current injury permitting) and, depending on England’s Six Nations form, either Jamie George or Theo Dan. Ellis Genge and Nicky Smith are probably contesting the last loosehead vacancy, with Ireland’s Finlay Bealham, born in Australia, as the third tighthead.
Second row
The 2025 squad will not be stuffed full of returning Lions. It may even be that Furlong and Maro Itoje are the only starting forwards from 2021 to retain their Test places, making the latter’s experience even more important. Again the Six Nations will be instructive but, at this distance, Ireland’s Joe McCarthy and James Ryan are the two main frontrunners to partner Itoje. A decent lineout presence will be essential, with the ex-England lock Geoff Parling now shaping Australia’s strategy in that area, and McCarthy’s impact could be key. The other option involves moving the excellent Tadhg Beirne up from the back row, where Andy Farrell will be keen to start him, or opting for Wales’s hard‑working Dafydd Jenkins. Either way, another mobile and versatile lineout forward will be required, with Ireland’s talented Ryan Baird looking to edge out Ollie Chessum and the evergreen Courtney Lawes.
Back row
Perhaps the trickiest selection conundrum of the lot. Caelan Doris, Ireland’s captain, would make an excellent Lions skipper and the consistent Josh van der Flier is another shoo-in. Add Tadhg Beirne and that potentially leaves just four more squad vacancies. Only three from Jac Morgan, Ben Earl, Jack Willis, Tom Curry, Sam Underhill and Rory Darge look certain to make it, with Willis’s form for Toulouse so good he will be difficult to ignore. There is just one snag: if Toulouse make the Top 14 final on 28 June the Englishman will in effect be unavailable for the first three games of the tour. That, in turn, could mean him starting the first Test on the bench, with Morgan and Earl taking the early-tour strain. The final slot will be earmarked for a hard-carrying, dynamic No 8, with Aaron Wainwright, Jack Conan, Jack Dempsey, Chandler Cunningham‑South, Taulupe Faletau, Taine Plumtree and Tom Willis all candidates. Wainwright would boost Wales’s representation, while the ex-Wallaby Dempsey could bring useful inside knowledge.
Half-backs
No Lions tour succeeds without a smart, influential pair of half-backs. Jamison Gibson-Park has been at the heart of Ireland’s finest displays and England’s Alex Mitchell and Wales’s Tomos Williams are next in line, ahead of Ben White, George Horne and Ben Spencer. Fly-half? Think back to the last Test the Lions played in Australia, in Sydney in 2013, and Johnny Sexton’s influence when the chips were down. Whether or not Finn Russell is Andy Farrell’s idea of a perfect 10, both he and Marcus Smith add spark to any side. Either way – and allowing for Smith’s occasional redeployment at full-back – a third 10 with another positional string to his bow will be needed. Is that Owen Farrell, not currently playing Test rugby? Or might Scotland’s Tom Jordan, who can also play 15, be the answer? Ireland’s Sam Prendergast and Ciarán Frawley will hope otherwise.
Midfield
If a team’s strength is best gauged by the names omitted, the 2025 Lions will be impressively strong. Robbie Henshaw, Ollie Lawrence, Henry Slade and Cam Redpath are all seriously talented but limited preparation time and shorter tours make it harder to forge dream partnerships – Brian O’Driscoll and Jamie Roberts, for example, in South Africa in 2009. Step forward “Huw-ipolotu” – the Glasgow and Scotland pairing of Sione Tuipolotu and Huw Jones and the steely Irish combo of Bundee Aki and Garry Ringrose. With Russell at 10, the Scotland duo would be accustomed to their conductor’s rhythm. And if things need tightening up and pressure needs applying to the Wallabies’ playmakers then Aki and Ringrose are perfectly suited. If Owen Farrell is missing, though, someone else needs to be versatile enough to fill in at centre. Ireland’s Jamie Osborne is already a player whom Andy Farrell admires.
Back three
Blair Kinghorn’s form for Toulouse makes him favourite to start at full-back. As with the aforementioned Willis, though, Kinghorn will struggle to feature in the first three games if his club make the Top 14 final. That further complicates Farrell’s task and it could boil down to a couple of straight shootouts: Hugo Keenan or Osborne as reserve full-back and either Jordan or Henshaw in a utility back role. On the wings Manny Feyi-Waboso, Duhan van der Merwe and James Lowe, if fit, all have the pedigree and strike rate to merit squad selection but the Wallabies’ aerial prowess may count against the brilliant but diminutive Darcy Graham. Farrell may prefer the Canberra-born Mack Hansen, England’s Tommy Freeman or Wales’s Liam Williams.
Possible British & Irish Lions starting XV and bench for first Test v Australia, Brisbane, 19 July: Blair Kinghorn (Scotland); Manny Feyi-Waboso (England), Huw Jones (Scotland), Sione Tuipolotu (Scotland), Duhan van der Merwe (Scotland); Finn Russell (Scotland), Jamison Gibson-Park (Ireland); Andrew Porter (Ireland), Dan Sheehan (Ireland), Tadhg Furlong (Ireland), Maro Itoje (England), Joe McCarthy (Ireland), Tadhg Beirne (Ireland), Josh van der Flier (Ireland), Caelan Doris (Ireland, capt).
Replacements: Dewi Lake (Wales), Pierre Schoeman (Scotland), Zander Fagerson (Scotland), James Ryan (Ireland), Ben Earl (England), Tomos Williams (Wales), Marcus Smith (England), Bundee Aki (Ireland).
• This is an extract taken from our weekly rugby union email, the Breakdown. To sign up, just visit this page and follow the instructions.
