Demarquette Easter egg clam
Average mark: 4.5/5
£25, 300g (£8.33/100g)
"What's a chocolate clam got to do with Easter?" mused one of our tasters before hastily adding "but I'm not complaining." Recording the highest average mark of any of the Easter chocolate products we tried, the thick shell "tastes as good as it looks" and contains "good sized, delicious caramel-filled chocolate eggs with a marbled pattern on the outside." Overall "a stonking product" Photograph: Sarah Lee/Guardian
paul.a.young sea salted caramel egg
Average mark: 3.75/5
£19.95, 90g (£22.17/100g)
OK, so this is in the over £20 category even though it costs 5p under the threshold, but it definitely belongs here. "Clever, tasty, teensy for the price (think two Cadbury's Creme Eggs) - and totally impractical" this egg comes with its own eggcup and china spoon and wowed our tasters. Inside the surprisingly tough shell there's "creamy, salty, buttery caramel" which is "is close to perfect, and if you can just ignore the price it's a total joy" Photograph: Sarah Lee/Guardian
Hotel Chocolat's The Eggsibitionist extra thick Easter egg
Average mark: 3/5
£26, 390g (£6.67/100g)
With its "proper thick milk chocolate and a good assortment inside" one taster felt this was "all that you would want an egg at the luxury end of the market to be." Opinion on the contents was divided, however, with another reporting "my small 'inner egg' was utterly foul" and a third finding "the raspberry one, in particular, is an acquired taste to put it mildly" Photograph: Sarah Lee/Guardian
Betty's Swiss dark chocolate Easter egg
Average mark: 2.5/5
£39, 600g (£6.50/100g)
This really is "a stupidly big egg" which "looks fabulous in an utterly Betty's of Harrogate sort of way" and is, if you're into this sort of thing, "every child's Willy Wonka inspired chocolate dream." The chocolate let it down, though, by just being "OK" Photograph: Sarah Lee/Guardian
Artisan du Chocolat butterfly egg
Average mark: 2/5
£29.99, 400g (£7.50/100g)
"Really looks the business ... until you put it in your mouth. Strangely flavour-free" Photograph: Sarah Lee/Guardian
Rococo hand painted dark chocolate egg
Average mark: 2/5
£25, 160g (£6.41/100g)
"The shell, which is made from different types of chocolate, is trying to do too much and as a result, not achieving very much at all. Overpriced and underwhelming" Photograph: Sarah Lee/Guardian
Harrods milk couverture Easter laced egg with rabbit
Average mark: 1.75/5
£29.95, 290g (£10.33/100g)
"Much like the Harrods Food Hall in which it is sold: very pretty to look at, but the underlying product simply isn't very good. The lattice-work shell will make a terrible mess of your carpet" Photograph: Sarah Lee/Guardian
Prestat rose and violet creme egg
Average mark: 1.5/5
£22.50, 227g (£9.91/100g)
"Chocolatiers to royalty really ought to know better than to come up with something that tastes of vaguely chocolate-flavoured pot pourri. Nasty" Photograph: Sarah Lee/Guardian
