Attorneys defending Tennessee's abortion ban argued that doctors challenging the law are withholding care to women facing serious medical emergencies. The Tennessee Attorney General's office is seeking to dismiss a lawsuit brought by nine women and two doctors, claiming that the current law violates pregnant patients’ right to life as guaranteed by the state’s constitution.
The lawsuit aims to clarify when abortion exceptions can be applied in the state, particularly in cases of fatal diagnoses. However, one judge expressed doubts about the panel's ability to redline a law approved by the General Assembly.
Both sides presented their case during a lengthy hearing, with the state arguing that doctors do not want oversight in their medical decision-making, while the plaintiffs contended that the law is overly broad and vague, leading to fear among doctors.
One plaintiff, Rebecca Milner, shared her experience of being denied abortion services in Tennessee and later diagnosed with sepsis after seeking care in Virginia. The state's legal team argued that the plaintiffs lack standing, but the judge noted that the local district attorney's statement not to prosecute abortion providers is not legally binding.
The decision on whether to dismiss the case or block the abortion ban temporarily is pending the panel's review of the full case. The lawsuit highlights the ongoing legal battle over abortion rights in Tennessee and the challenges faced by women seeking reproductive healthcare in the state.
