Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Wales Online
Wales Online
Sport
Delme Parfitt

South Africa v Wales winners and losers as Pivac earns respite and personal horror show unfolds

Wales’ latest defeat to South Africa was one that will live long in the memory of supporters from both nations.

It was a match full of twists and turns and, as ever, there was good, bad, and a fair bit of ugly.

So who were the winners and losers at Loftus Versfeld? Try these for size.

SIGN-UP: Get the latest rugby news delivered straight into your inbox for FREE!

WINNERS

Tommy Reffell

Making your senior international debut is one thing, doing it against a world champion Springbok team at altitude is a different prospect entirely.

So take a bow Tommy Reffell.

Initial match stats suggested the 23-year-old Leicester Tigers flanker had made 15 tackles, which said it all about his industriousness and work ethic.

One crucial turnover on Jasper Wiese in the first half stands out because it stymied a South African attack which was looking likely to yield a try.

But that was just a snapshot of a hugely productive and mature performance for someone getting a first taste of the Test arena.

Another quality back row player rolls off a permanently fruitful Welsh conveyor belt.

Wayne Pivac

When you are the head coach you take the flak in defeat and vice versa.

This was not actually a victory, but, as perverse at it may sound, it felt like one.

Pivac has presided over just 11 wins in 28 matches since taking over from Warren Gatland after the 2019 World Cup.

That’s not good enough by some margin and only a fool would consider his slate to be wiped clean by this.

Furthermore, you wonder just how critical the influence of his lieutenants Stephen Jones and Gethin Jenkins was to this turnaround. Both of those have so much experience of fronting up to South Africa in their own back yard.

Yet Pivac is the main man, and this has the potential to be a turning point.

The New Zealander has admitted to sleepless nights since the loss to Italy in March and has clearly been feeling the pressure.

The nature of this display has lifted that pressure somewhat.

But it’s just a start….

Rate the Wales players here

The Loftus crowd

This was the first time since 2019 that a sell-out crowd had been allowed to watch South Africa due to the ravages of Covid.

They got their money’s worth – and how!

Most home fans probably expected an easier time of things for their team, but what a Test match, what entertainment – and for them, the right team won in the end.

It was an occasion to reflect on just what rugby means to nations like South Africa, and to reinforce the notion that top level sport is nothing without the people.

Damien Willemse

The Springbok full-back took on the goal-kicking duties in the second half after hapless No10 Elton Jantjies was hooked at the interval before he inflicted more damage on his own team through his jittery and error-strewn display.

He knocked over a modest seven points with the boot, but it was his accuracy under pressure which stood out.

Not only did he slot the winning penalty in injury-time, he also landed a brilliant conversion from the touchline of Cheslin Kolbe’s 66th minute score.

He stepped up to become the difference between victory and defeat and deserves credit for doing so.

LOSERS

Dan Biggar

The Wales captain wasn’t all bad. His first-half drop goal and his in-your-face enthusiasm helped fire his side at important times.

But his slowing up of the ball after hauling down Faf de Klerk in the second half saw him yellow carded, and while he was off the Boks scored through Bongi Mbonombi.

Then he missed that last-gasp conversion attempt that would have put Wales ahead with about a minute and half left, before conceding the last gasp penalty that, although harsh, ultimately decided the match

It wasn’t the easiest of kicks, but you would still have expected a kicked of his experience and quality to get it.

Biggar has played far worse in his time, including for Wales. But as he will remember this match for all the wrong reasons, he ended it firmly in the losers camp.

Elton Jantjies

There was speculation beforehand that the Boks would sorely miss fly-half Handre Pollard and that there was precious little depth in the position available to the world champions right now.

None of that talk said much for Jantjies, but frankly his performance did nothing but justify the sentiments.

He spooned an easy penalty wide early on and then got too greedy going for touch and minored the ball – much to the dismay of the home fans.

He was pulled off at half-time, a change which capped a personal horror show and one from which he may struggle to return. We’ll see.

All in all, not a good night for outside-halves.

Faf de Klerk

He’s one of the golden boys of the World Cup winning squad and rightly so, De Klerk is a top scrum-half.

But his display epitomised the rustiness of South Africa before half-time.

De Klerk’s kicking was woeful the entire time he was out there and he failed to provide the control for which he is renowned.

Class is permanent however, so we can probably expect something special from him in the second Test.

Alun Wyn Jones

When the Lions skipper replaced Adam Beard in the 51st minute it was probably as part of a script that saw him being the safe pair of hands and assured leadership contributor that would get Wales home with the win.

But his impact was limited, and he couldn’t prevent his pack carelessly rolling a lineout maul into touch at a crucial moment in the second half.

Then came the yellow card that precipitated Wales’ eventual downfall.

There would have been nobody more frustrated than the great lock come the final whistle.

  • Dan Biggar denies any wrongdoing in moment that lost the game
  • Wales suffer agony in Test match for the ages as excruciating turning point sees history slip away
  • South Africa v Wales match halted for seven minutes amid concerning scenes
  • Australia v England halted as Tom Banks suffers gruesome injury and Sky Sports commentators apologise for replays
  • Australia giant sent off for headbutting England star who pulled his hair
  • All Blacks star's 'sickening' challenge against Ireland sparks furore as officials stand accused
  • Sign up to read this article
    Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
    Already a member? Sign in here
    Related Stories
    Top stories on inkl right now
    One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
    Already a member? Sign in here
    Our Picks
    Fourteen days free
    Download the app
    One app. One membership.
    100+ trusted global sources.