Sapore restaurant in the Sheldon area of Birmingham has racked up an impressive 4.5 star rating on TripAdvisor, with over 300 reviews.
Last year the Italian eatery was even awarded a Travellers' Choice Award.
However, the establishment has recently faced harsh criticism from a customer, who left a 'rude' review on the rating site.
The unnamed critic visited the restaurant to celebrate a birthday and claimed they'd have been better off if they'd gone to Toby Carvery instead.
The owner of Sapore has since responded to the comments, hitting back at the writer as they didn't mention any of their negative thoughts during their meal.
Get the news you want straight to your inbox. Sign up for a Mirror newsletter here.
The one-star reviewer titled their post saying: "Awful 'Italian'. Avoid it is overpriced and the food is poor".
Their full review read: "We went for a meal to Sapore to celebrate my 60th with my mother and children. The restaurant was very quite bad it was 2pm on Sunday afternoon.
"This though didn’t mean we were served very efficiently as the waiter seemed on a go-slow throughout. To start we ordered the seafood platter which was incredibly salty and was well dull and uninspiring. The platter included some of the prawn and crab cocktail which was ordered by two of our party again it was very insipid.
"Our main courses included a Margherita pizza which is hard to ruin, the Valtellina pizza… which was according to my son awful. My mother had the langoustine pasta which still had the gritty stomach inside so that was not a pleasant surprise.
"My lamb was over-cooked and the sauce was sour… it was also accompanied by roast potatoes which were soft and not at all crispy. The other main course was a carbonara which to be honest could have been out of a jar .
"The poor food and almost arrogantly slow service made us wish we had gone to the Toby Carvery up the road! I can’t understand how anyone could give the restaurant any good reviews."
The unnamed owner responded to say it was a "shame" that the diner didn't share their comments on the day of their visit, instead of writing a review on Tripadvisor.
Their lengthy reply didn't hold back, as they said: "Thank you for taking your time to write this review. We are always open and happy to listen to constructive feedback as none is perfect and there is always room for an improvement.
"It is only a shame that you didn't decide to share your comments with us on the day you dined at Sapore. It is very bizarre that your food was so awful and disappointing as you managed to finish it all. Nothing was mentioned to your servers, who would have been more than happy to rectify any problems you might have had.
"Regarding your food: Seafood platter - did you ask your server what does it include? Maybe if you would have done so you would have been informed that it is served with prawn and crab cocktail...
"Lamb - as the menu states, it is served with white wine and rosemary sauce; that should indicate that the sauce won't be sweet but a little bit acidic (as the white wine is). Carbonara - all our pasta are made to order, so please let us assure you that your carbonara wasn't from the jar.
"Langoustine pasta - we actually take all the flesh out of the shells and leave the shell just as a presentation, therefore not really sure about your gritty stomach comment. Pizza - again, if it was so awful why was it eaten and nothing was mentioned on the day?
"Regarding the speed of service, I do understand you might to be served quicker at Toby Carvery, as obviously, they don't cook your food to order.
"Everything is pre-cooked and just re-heated there. That's not the case at Sapore, I do afraid.
"Sapore prides itself on guest satisfaction and produce quality. We are very sorry once again that we didn't meet your expectations on this occasion.
"That being said we would rather preferred a direct contact or even a conversation on the day you dine with us rather than using Tripadvisor as this leaves no way of addressing the issues. Hope we all agree that our restaurant is not for you as there was clearly nothing you enjoyed...
"We wish you all the best in your future dining experiences. Sapore team."
Despite the negative review, hundreds of people have praised Sapore on TripAdvisor, with some branding it "excellent" and sharing how "staff went above and beyond".
Last week, Andy said: "Just discovered this restaurant. Been twice in the past three weeks.
"Lovely place, exceptional food and fantastic service. Had the bruschetta al fungi, polpette, calamari, amatriciana, lasagne, cacciatore and agnello al forno. All fantastic dishes."
Meanwhile, in March, another reviewer wrote: "First time here, four of us for birthday evening meal. Staff and manager are bubbly happy staff went above and beyond to see we had everything we wanted.
"Drinks starters main course desert Irish coffees came out to us with perfection there is nothing they could have improved on. I will most definitely be back."
Do you have a story to share? We pay for stories. Email us at yourmirror@mirror.co.uk
