Residents of East Palestine, Ohio, are facing a crucial decision regarding a $600 million class-action settlement with Norfolk Southern following a train derailment last year. The settlement offers compensation to those living within 20 miles of the incident, with varying amounts based on proximity to the crash site.
Individuals residing within 10 miles must decide whether to accept up to $25,000 for personal injuries, forfeiting the right to sue for future health issues related to chemical exposure. Those closest to the derailment could receive $70,000 for property damage, while others may only get a few hundred dollars.
Concerns have been raised about the lack of transparency regarding testing results conducted by an expert, Stephen Petty, hired by attorneys representing the residents. Attorney David Graham filed a motion requesting the disclosure of this crucial information to address residents' uncertainties.
During a recent town hall meeting, a different expert, Dr. Arch Carson, downplayed the risk of cancer development due to the derailment, citing limited EPA tests. However, ongoing health studies in the area suggest that the long-term effects of the incident may not be fully understood for years.
Graham has criticized the plaintiffs' attorneys, suggesting their focus may be on securing legal fees rather than prioritizing residents' interests. Despite these concerns, the attorneys have defended the settlement, emphasizing its size and the standard evaluation period provided to residents.
Residents have also expressed frustration over the tight opt-out deadline set shortly after a National Transportation Safety Board hearing on the derailment investigation. The uncertainty surrounding the settlement and potential health risks has left many residents seeking more time and information before making a decision.
