During her closing argument, state prosecutor Sheila Ross detailed the charges faced by Jose Ibarra, labeling him as a 'monstrously guilty individual.' Ross urged Judge H. Patrick Haggard to find Ibarra guilty on all counts.
Malice Murder
Ross emphasized Ibarra's deliberate intent to kill, citing evidence from the medical examiner. She described how Ibarra used a rock to inflict fatal injuries on the victim, stating that there was no other motive than to silence her permanently.
Felony Murder (3 counts)
- Kidnapping with Bodily Injury: Ross explained how Ibarra moved the victim off the trail to carry out his intentions.
- Aggravated Assault with Intent to Rape: Ross highlighted the victim's state of undress and physical injuries, indicating a sexual assault motive.
- Aggravated Battery: Ross pointed out the severe injuries sustained by the victim.
Obstruction of 911 Call
Ross presented evidence showing that the victim's emergency call was disconnected, with Ibarra's thumbprint found on the phone. She argued that Ibarra deliberately hung up the call.
Felony Tampering with Evidence
Ross referenced video footage allegedly showing Ibarra disposing of incriminating items on the day of the crime, including bloody clothing and gloves.
Peeping Tom
Ross detailed an incident where Ibarra was observed peering into a graduate student's apartment. The student reported feeling unsettled by the encounter, with security footage corroborating her account.
The prosecution's case against Ibarra is built on a comprehensive examination of the evidence, painting a disturbing picture of the events leading to the victim's tragic death.
