Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
AAP
AAP
Health
Alex Mitchell

Parents reveal toll of devastating hospital death

Leah Pitman (left) and Dustin Atkinson believe better care could have saved their daughter's life. (HANDOUT/ABC)

Parents of a baby who died after being treated at a controversial hospital believe their daughter could have been saved with better medical care.

Harper Atkinson suffered complications at birth at Sydney's Northern Beaches Hospital in February, before her death at a separate facility the following day.

The 488-bed facility is subject to a public-private healthcare partnership, which the NSW government has vowed to prevent in the future.

Northern Beaches Hospital
Northern Beaches Hospital is subject to a public-private healthcare partnership. (Dan Himbrechts/AAP PHOTOS)

It is the same hospital where toddler Joe Massa collapsed and died in September 2024 after his parents waited three hours at the hospital's emergency department.

Private operator Healthscope has admitted that was an "unacceptable failing".

Harper's mother Leah Pitman was sent for an emergency caesarean section but was forced to wait for the on-call team to arrive at the hospital and begin surgery.

"There was blood in my waters and I just remember looking down at the floor and thinking 'oh, God, is that normal?' I started getting pain in between contractions," she told ABC TV.

Northern Beaches does not run a 24-hour theatre on weekend nights, with an on-call team required to attend within 30 minutes to meet legal and ethical guidelines.

Ms Pitman said she was "incredibly angry" she had been forced to wait, rather than receiving immediate treatment that she felt could have saved her daughter.

"I remember asking them … 'why aren't we going anywhere?' They kept explaining, 'theatre is not ready, theatre is not ready'," she told ABC News.

"I'm obviously sad every single day she's not here with us, but (there is) so much anger and frustration knowing that she could be, and that her death, we feel, was completely preventable."

Ms Pitman gave birth to Harper less than an hour after the call for an emergency C-section.

Northern Beaches Hospital
Healthscope has indicated it wants to return control of Northern Beaches Hospital to public hands. (Dan Himbrechts/AAP PHOTOS)

Harper did not take her first breath for 21 minutes, and her parents turned off life support the next day.

Healthscope would not discuss the specifics of the death as an official review is under way, but defended its on-call approach on weekends.

"(It is) in line with NSW health policy; the obstetric cover at NBH also meets The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists' guidelines for emergency caesarean sections," a spokesman said.

"Our clinicians have met with the family to help answer their questions and queries … any recommendations or learnings arising from the review will be implemented as appropriate."

Healthscope has indicated it would like to return control of Northern Beaches Hospital to public hands amid financial restructuring and moves to outlaw similar partnership models in Australia's largest health system.

Healthscope, which operates 38 hospitals across the country, remains contracted to operate the Northern Beaches Hospital until 2038.

But financial turmoil at the Canadian-controlled firm has placed its future in doubt.

An auditor-general's report into the performance of the hospital will be released on Thursday, with an assessment of how effectively and efficiently it delivers services. 

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.