Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
AAP
AAP
Jacob Shteyman

No bunker error despite Eels' obstruction protests: NRL

NRL HQ has defended a call which cost the Eels a try, and victory, against rivals Penrith. (Mark Evans/AAP PHOTOS)

The NRL has backed the bunker's decision not to overturn Penrith's game-winning try against Parramatta, despite a Panthers player clearly knocking over an Eels defender in the build-up.

The Eels were left furious over what they believed was an apparent obstruction from Liam Martin on Deajarn Asi in Penrith's 36-34 win on Friday night.

Trying to create a break out of their own end, Martin ran through as a decoy runner and bowled over Asi, who was left sprawled on the turf and unable to take part in the play, as Daine Laurie sprinted down field and put Izack Tago over.

Parramatta captain Clint Gutherson immediately raised the issue with referee Peter Gough, and the play was reviewed by the bunker before the try was confirmed. 

Izack Tago.
Izack Tago crashes over for the Panthers' dramatic final try against Parramatta. (Mark Evans/AAP PHOTOS)

Laurie caught the ball beyond the outside shoulder of Martin, but the Eels were adamant the contact still impacted their defensive movements.

"How that happens with the officiating that we've got and how many people are looking at it, I don't know," Eels coach Trent Barrett said.

"Daejarn Asi just got knocked over by Liam and it shouldn't have been a try."

But the NRL's head of football operations Graham Annesley said an incidental collision with Blaize Talagi caused Martin to trip over and unintentionally interfere with Asi.

Then as play continues, the ball-carrier does not benefit from the collision as he does not run back into that area of the field.

"I'm the first to acknowledge that there'll be different points of view on this," Annesley said on Monday. 

"But is this an obviously incorrect decision by the bunker? No, it's not. It's a perfectly valid explanation by the bunker of why they reached the decision that, in their view, this was not an obstruction that required intervention."

Annesley did acknowledge a refereeing blunder cost Canberra a try in their 46-24 loss to Manly on Saturday.

The Raiders were disallowed a try when referee Grant Atkins blew the whistle prematurely with utility player Adam Cook clean through for a try.

What had appeared to the naked eye to be a clear knock-on turned out to be a deft grubber kick on replay. 

Josh Papalii.
Josh Papalii is left disappointed after a controversial moment in the Raiders-Sea Eagles clash. (Lukas Coch/AAP PHOTOS)

The Raiders were successful in challenging the on-field call, confirming Cook had scored a legal try.

But Atkins' early whistle meant it could not be awarded, as it prevented Trbojevic from attempting to chase Cook, even if he would not have been able to track him down.

Annesley said it was fair to ask whether the referee should have allowed play to continue before blowing the whistle, although that could then run the risk of not being able to call play back in case Trbojevic made the tackle and it did turn out to be a knock-on.

But he opened the door for the NRL to review the rule at the end of the season.

"No doubt this situation will be looked at. Could the laws of the game be changed to cater for this in a different way? Of course, because we changed it a few years ago," he said.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.