Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Newcastle Herald
Newcastle Herald
National

Negotiations, deals and guilty pleas as part of court's 'super callover'

A WOMAN who spent eight months behind bars accused of shooting a man during a terrifying home invasion at Gateshead pleads guilty to a lesser charge and is convicted with no further penalty.

Two men, who until as recently as last week were denying any involvement or knowledge of another shooting at Muswellbrook, step forward and take a plea deal.

Others, charged with massive drug importation, armed robbery, causing fatal crashes and even more shootings, refuse to budge.

Specialist police examining the scene at Gateshead following the shooting on May 18 last year. Picture by Jonathan Carroll
Specialist police examining the scene at Gateshead following the shooting on May 18 last year. Picture by Jonathan Carroll
Specialist police examining the scene at Gateshead following the shooting on May 18 last year. Picture by Jonathan Carroll
Specialist police examining the scene at Gateshead following the shooting on May 18 last year. Picture by Jonathan Carroll
Police released CCTV footage of this man, captured shortly before the shooting in Gateshead last year.
Specialist police examining the scene at Gateshead following the shooting on May 18 last year. Picture by Jonathan Carroll
Specialist police examining the scene at Gateshead following the shooting on May 18 last year. Picture by Jonathan Carroll
Specialist police examining the scene at Gateshead following the shooting on May 18 last year. Picture by Jonathan Carroll
Specialist police examining the scene at Gateshead following the shooting on May 18 last year. Picture by Jonathan Carroll
Specialist police examining the scene at Gateshead following the shooting on May 18 last year. Picture by Jonathan Carroll

Welcome to Newcastle District Court's super callover, where defended criminal matters are funnelled into a list, negotiations are encouraged and deals are done to reduce the backlog of criminal trials.

In the past these super callovers in Newcastle have managed to entice guilty pleas out of hundreds of defendants and clear just as many trials, creating space for more trials to fill the void.

On Wednesday, it was Sarah Winwood's turn.

Once charged with discharging a firearm and intending to cause grievous bodily harm and specially aggravated break and enter over a shooting in Flame Street in the early hours of May 26 last year, Winwood spent eight months behind bars.

Those charges were dropped, she was granted bail and she was charged with hindering the discovery of evidence after police said she destroyed a black jacket linked to the shooting.

She pleaded not guilty to that charge and was expected to face a trial in May next year.

But her matter was sucked into the super callover and on Wednesday, she pleaded guilty to concealing the shooting from police.

Winwood's barrister, Public Defender Peter Krisenthal, said she should be convicted with no further penalty imposed and she was dealt with on the spot, the five-day trial date next year vacated to, no doubt, make room for another matter.

Judge Roy Ellis took into account the time she had spent behind bars and the fact she was in a toxic relationship with one of the shooters, which he said provided some explanation as to why she didn't turn him in to police.

Meanwhile, Dallas Kimber and Bradley Carpenter were last week expected to face a trial over a shooting at Muswellbrook before it was suddenly aborted.

The pair were promptly funneled into the super callover list and on Wednesday, after negotiations between prosecutors and defence, admitted to being involved.

Kimber pleaded guilty to firing a firearm in a manner likely to injure and recklessly causing grievous bodily harm to a man in Anzac Parade on June 27, 2022, while Carpenter admitted to hindering the discovery of evidence by hiding the firearm and a shell casing.

Kimber did not have his bail revoked after pleading guilty, but Crown prosecutor Jillian Kelton said that should not be viewed as "reflective of the prosecution's position on sentence".

The pair will be sentenced in March.

The super callover continues.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.