Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Daily Mirror
Daily Mirror
National
Marcello Mega & Laura Sharman

Mum almost died from cervical cancer after doctors gave 'wrong' smear test results

A mum almost died of cervical cancer after previously being given the wrong result for a routine smear test.

Sarah Feighan, 32, said she thought she was going to die when she was finally diagnosed with cancer.

A routine smear test in 2013 detected multiple pre-cancerous cells, but she was told the results were negative.

By the time the disease was spotted in 2018, she said doctors were talking about how to prolong her life rather than cure it.

Now she is urging people to turn up for every smear test and to be sure their results have been recorded accurately.

"I thought I was going to die," Sarah told the Liverpool Echo.

"By the time I was diagnosed, I was desperately ill. The medics were talking about prolonging my life for as long as possible rather than giving me hope of being cured.

The young mum almost died of cervical cancer (Daily Record)

"The really galling thing – and I only learned this last year when a lawyer acting for me demanded paperwork from my original smear in 2013 – was that the first smear had detected many pre-cancerous cells."

Sarah was originally given the wrong results by Forth Valley Health Board, and was eventually diagnosed with “neuro­endocrine small cell cancer” five years later.

In a series of urgent treatments, doctors had to remove Sarah's womb in an operation that has left her unable to urinate naturally and dependent on a catheter for the rest of her life.

Sarah said: "The document I was sent back by Forth Valley Health Board said my test was ‘negative’ but the actual results told a different story.

"I should have been called back for a colposcopy and might have needed wire loop ­treatment, which I know is not pleasant but would have been preferable to developing full-blown cervical cancer."

Sarah, who now lives in Manchester, had an English law firm trying to bring a civil claim against the board. However, counsel’s opinion took them below the 70 per cent chance of success estimate they apply to take cases on a no-win, no-fee basis.

Sarah had been called back for another routine smear in 2016 but didn’t attend due to major stresses in her personal life, and her condition would have been picked up at that point.

She said: "The legal argument was there might not have been ­significant changes between 2013 and 2016 because I only started to experience symptoms around 2017, with pain and bleeding.

"So it was considered arguable that I had contributed to my misfortune. But if I had been given any indication that I had anything to worry about, of course I’d have gone back for the smear in 2016."

Sarah, who works in security, said she had not yet decided whether to seek another lawyer.

She said: "The main reason I’m speaking out is not so I can gain from it but so others can be aware mistakes do happen and sometimes they are catastrophic.

"I just want women to know that this can happen to you when you’re young, so go and get the smears when they’re offered, and do what you can, maybe through your own GP, to make sure the results are correct.

"I can hardly put into words how let down I feel by the NHS.”

NHS Forth Valley said it followed the national cervical screening programme which includes systems for checking, reviewing and monitoring results.

A spokesperson continued: "The programme does not diagnose cancer but it’s extremely important that when invited you attend your screening."

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.