Two weeks into the MLS regular season, and one of the biggest stories has nothing to do with star-studded teams like Inter Miami CF or the LA Galaxy. The ongoing use of replacement referees in Major League Soccer has sparked controversy and conversation within the North American soccer community.
The Professional Referee Organization (PRO), funded by Major League Soccer, locked out referees from the Professional Soccer Referees Association (PSRA) on Feb. 18 after the PSRA rejected a tentative agreement. Negotiations for a new collective bargaining agreement have hit roadblocks, with PRO threatening to impose reduced terms if not approved by March 11.
More than 10 replacement referees have been sourced from top leagues in countries like Brazil, Turkey, Spain, Italy, Jamaica, Mexico, and Poland. Additionally, former or current national referees from U.S. Soccer and officials from lower-tier, collegiate, and youth ranks in the U.S. have been brought in.
Despite concerns, the league continues to stand by its decision to use replacement referees, betting that the gains at the bargaining table will outweigh any negative impact. While some controversial incidents have occurred, such as erroneous calls affecting game outcomes, the league maintains that the performance of replacement referees aligns with past standards.
While some coaches and team executives acknowledge the challenges faced by replacement referees, there is a general sentiment that mistakes are not exclusive to them. The difference in experience levels between replacement referees and union referees is a point of discussion, with varying opinions on the impact of the change.
Statistics show that the rate of VAR interventions and overturned calls has increased in the current season compared to previous years. Despite criticisms, the league asserts that the replacement referees are meeting professional standards, although some former officials and experts point out instances of inexperience affecting game flow and decision-making.
The ongoing debate surrounding the use of replacement referees in MLS highlights the complexities of balancing labor negotiations, officiating standards, and the integrity of the game. As the season progresses, the impact of this decision on the league and its stakeholders remains a topic of interest and scrutiny.
