David de Gea
Fine save from Rodrigo de Paul at 0-0 and was beaten at his near post by Renan Lodi for the winning goal. 6
Diogo Dalot
Adventurous in attack but asleep at the back to let Lodi score and failed to regain the confidence he played with prior to then. 4
Raphael Varane
Read the game well amid Harry Maguire's sloppiness and was unfortunate to be denied by Jan Oblak from a free-kick. 7
Read more: United highlights and reaction vs Atletico Madrid
Harry Maguire
Some clumsy moments in both boxes and awkward in possession. The crowd almost turned against him. When he was substituted, several did. 4
Alex Telles
Started by default in the absence of Luke Shaw. Never on the same wavelength as Jadon Sancho and porous in his own third. 4
Scott McTominay
Another performance where he did not lack commitment but did lack quality against superior midfielders. 4
Fred
Brimming with confidence after his performance against Tottenham and he transmitted it to the first-half. Quieter in the second. 6
Anthony Elanga
Should have scored with a point-blank chance and went down easily to gift Atletico possession they profited from. 5
Bruno Fernandes
Lacked sharpness and became easily agitated by the referee. Rightly substituted for the final quarter of the match. 5
Jadon Sancho
His poorest performance for a while, particularly as he was up against an auxiliary right-back in Marco Llorente. 4
Cristiano Ronaldo
Understandably committed and eager but had no joy against Atletico's obdurate defence almost all of the night. 5
Subs
Paul Pogba
Little impact. 5
Marcus Rashford
Toiled. 4
Nemanja Matic
Brought expertise. 5
Edinson Cavani
Next to no service. 4
Juan Mata
No impact. 5
Manager
Refusing to consider Pogba as a starter off the left was a mistake and McTominay's instant recall was not vindicated. Made proactive changes but should have made some earlier. 5
