Maine Secretary of State Shenna Bellows recently made a decision stating that former President Donald Trump engaged in insurrection during the events of January 6, 2021. Bellows held a public hearing before making this decision, thoroughly analyzing Section 3 of the 14th Amendment. Despite some opposition, including a statement from Democratic Congressman Jared Golden, who argued that Trump should be allowed on the ballot until proven guilty of insurrection, Belles remained steadfast in her ruling.
Bellows Belles emphasized that the unprecedented events of January 6th constituted an attack on the Capitol, government officials, the former vice president, and members of Congress. She emphasized that this attack was also an assault on the rule of law. The weight of the evidence presented to her during the hearing indicated that it was indeed an insurrection, in which Trump was involved.
As the case from Colorado awaits a potential Supreme Court review, some legal analysts have raised doubts about whether the Court will rule specifically on the definition of engaging in an insurrection and whether criminality must be proven. Belles, however, stated that she will always implement the decisions of the court, highlighting that similar proceedings are not uncommon in her role as Maine Secretary of State. She mentioned previous cases where her decisions were upheld by the court, reinforcing her commitment to upholding their rulings.
Belles acknowledged the tight timeline for resolving the matter before the printing of ballots, expressing her hope that it can be done in time. To account for this, she suspended the effect of her decision until the courts can act, ensuring that no ballots are printed until a final decision is reached. In the event that the US Supreme Court determines that Trump should be on the ballot, Bellows affirmed that she will comply and include him as per their ruling.
The outcome of this decision has significant implications for Maine's electoral process and the 2024 presidential election. Belles' determination that Trump engaged in insurrection could potentially bar him from being included on the state's ballot if the court upholds her decision. However, the final decision rests with the Supreme Court.
The timing of the court's ruling will be crucial, as the printing of ballots cannot be delayed indefinitely. Bellows remains hopeful that a resolution can be reached in a timely manner to ensure a smooth electoral process.
