Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - US
The Guardian - US
World
Guardian staff and agencies

Lone survivor of migrant boat: ‘Mentally I was suffering … but I did not lose hope’

Juan Esteban Montoya Caicedo’s sister was among the group of about 40 migrants who drowned. ‘Everybody was holding on to everybody. That’s why she drowned,’ he said.
Juan Esteban Montoya Caicedo’s sister was among the roughly 40 migrants who drowned. ‘Everybody was holding on to everybody. That’s why she drowned,’ he said. Photograph: Cody Jackson/AP

The sole survivor of a capsized boat found near Florida’s coast said at least 15 other migrants tried to cling to the overturned vessel but couldn’t hold on, some desperately tired and hungry when they let go.

Juan Esteban Montoya Caicedo, of Colombia, told a Spanish-language news conference in Fort Pierce, Florida, that a baby girl and other children were among the group of 40 that included Dominicans, Haitians, Bahamians and Jamaicans.

They set out for Florida from Bimini in the Bahamas on 22 January. His younger sister was part of the group but drowned, he said.

Montoya told of the engine breaking down and authorities had said the boat capsized shortly after departing.

At the press conference, Montoya, 22, was seated next to his mother, Marcia Caicedo, who had traveled from Houston, Texas, to be with him.

He and his sister, María Camila Montoya, 18, had been heading for the US coast in an effort to reunite with their mother.

He said the motor broke down in the early hours of 23 January and the boat was adrift in choppy seas for about four hours, adding that he told his sister to pray, prepare for the worst and hold on to the vessel.

But then a giant wave overturned the boat and the two were separated. People were in a life or death battle for survival.

“I managed to see her again. But as I went to her to help her, the rest of the people were grabbing her. Everybody was holding on to everybody. That’s why she drowned,” he said.

A smaller group held on to the boat, but as hours passed, the group got smaller, Montoya said.

“What we were going through was so difficult, some people let go,” he said. “The lack of food, the lack of water and lack of rest affects you, and it led them to go that route.”

A man sits on the hull of an overturned boat in the middle of the ocean.
Juan Esteban Montoya Caicedo clings to the capsized boat off the coast of Florida. ‘When I was left alone it was harder, much harder,’ he said. Photograph: US Coast Guard/Zuma Press Wire Service/Rex/Shutterstock

Montoya said others still clung to the boat until Monday afternoon. It would be another day before his rescue.

“When I was left alone it was harder, much harder. My health was worsening, mentally I was suffering. Being alone was one more blow,” he said. “But I did not lose hope.”

Montoya spent two days holding on to the 25ft boat before he was rescued last Tuesday.

He said much of the time he was in the water holding on to the motor where he felt warmer, but the night before his rescue he had climbed up on to the overturned hull, where his image was captured by someone in a merchant vessel the day he was found.

Montoya said the two siblings were migrating, searching for a better life and safety.

His attorney, Naimeh Salem, said he would apply for political asylum but said she could not reveal more details about his case.

Montoya said they decided to try their luck at sea after looking on the internet and finding groups that said it was easier to migrate to the US that way than by land. A majority of migrants typically travel through Central America and Mexico to get to the US border.

Authorities are investigating the disaster as a suspected human smuggling operation gone awry.

“Criminals tell you it is safe,” Montoya said. “They tell you that in three or four hours you will be in Miami coming from the Bahamas, that you are going on a good boat. They tell you that you are only traveling with a few people and with a life jacket – all of that is a lie.”

They still decided to get on the boat because they felt desperate to reach the US, he said. Montoya said he believed he managed to survive to be able to tell his parents what had happened to his sister.

“I hope that God has something very big for me since my heart is now broken,” he said. “A part of me was taken.”

Their mother, Marcia Caicedo, said her daughter’s body had not been recovered, but she had stayed in touch with the US Coast Guard, which suspended the search for the missing last Thursday after finding five bodies.

Caicedo said she wished the search would have continued, adding that the pain of her loss just keeps growing and “the nights last forever”.

“But here I am staying strong for my son,” she said. “I will give him all the strength and support he needs.”

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.