Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Edinburgh Live
Edinburgh Live
National
Marie Sharp

Landowner 'aggrieved' by East Lothian planners refusal to let him build new house

A landowner whose plans to build a house on a country estate were rejected by planners despite receiving backing from Scottish Ministers has appealed the decision.

Agents for David McMillan say he was 'aggrieved' by the decision by East Lothian planners, who rejected his plans to replace a derelict headmaster's house on his land with a new home because he had moved it from the original site.

And they say planners have 'misrepresented' the application by describing it as a new build in the countryside.

READ MORE: East Lothian councillor warns people would be 'hungry, sober and naked' without farmers

The case will now be heard by East Lothian Council's Local Review Body when it meets next month.

Mr McMillan was given the go ahead to rebuild a family home on the site of a former schoolmaster’s house on the Whittingehame Estate, near Stenton, after appealing to Scottish Ministers three years ago..

The application was originally refused by East Lothian Council planners because it was more than a decade since the original house collapsed on the grounds.

However Scottish Ministers overturned the decision, ruling that the fact a home had been on the land before made it brownfield and allowed a new home to be built.

Planners said approving the new application, which received 16 letters of support, risked allowing the applicant to build two separate houses on the land.

And they claimed the design of the new larger home was more suited to a modern housing estate than a historical country one.

Rejecting the application they said: “As planning permission has already been granted for a replacement house on the adjacent site and as that planning permission has been implemented, this now proposed house cannot be a replacement for the former house.

“If planning permission was granted the applicant would have planning permission for two houses.”

In the appeal to next month's Local Review Body agents for Mr McMillan reject the suggestion he could build two homes on the land.

They say: "He is aggrieved by the council's decision.

"East Lothian Council planners have misrepresented this application and considered it as a new dwelling in the countryside, despite the clear intention of the applicant that this should be a like for like replacement.

"The existing consent would be revoked and extinguished by agreement allowing the replacement dwelling to be built.

"The applicant is not seeking to circumvent planning policy and achieve an extra house in the countryside."

READ NEXT:

Young East Lothian sport stars get green light to keep purple training centre

East Lothian distillery no longer has to warn neighbours of events

Edinburgh Marathon beer tent wins early opening to serve fastest racers

East Lothian windfarm facing fight from nuclear power station over sale of land

Controversial private East Lothian car park approved despite no Saturday opening

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.