Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
AAP
AAP
National
Ethan James

Patriarchy 'smashed': ladies' win in lounge legal fight

A judge has quashed a finding that an art gallery's ladies' lounge discriminated against men. (Ethan James/AAP PHOTOS)

An art gallery that closed its ladies' lounge after it was ruled discriminatory towards men is celebrating a "patriarchy-smashing" legal win that could lead to its reopening. 

Tasmania's Museum of Old and New Art (MONA) shut the lounge in April after NSW man Jason Lau complained to the state's civil and administrative tribunal because he wasn't allowed entry.

The tribunal found Mr Lau had been discriminated against and ordered MONA to allow men access, something the gallery wasn't prepared to do. 

MONA appealed in the Supreme Court of Tasmania, which on Friday quashed the tribunal's decision, ruling it had mischaracterised what the lounge intended to achieve.

The court ordered the tribunal to reconsider its decision.

MONA successfully argued the lounge addressed ongoing disadvantage faced by women.

"The patriarchy (has been) smashed and the verdict demonstrates a simple truth, women are better than men," artist and lounge curator Kirsha Kaechele said outside court.

"It's a day of triumph for us, and we're very excited". 

MONA's lawyer Catherine Scott is confident the tribunal will grant the lounge an exemption, and therefore permission to reopen, after its reconsideration. 

Kirsha Kaechele
Kirsha Kaechele said there were plans for a ladies' lounge celebration. (Ethan James/AAP PHOTOS)

Ms Kaechele, the wife of MONA founder David Walsh, said an announcement would be made soon.

"Something will happen with the ladies' lounge. There are plans in the works ... some kind of celebration," she said. 

The tribunal had erred by claiming the lounge only addressed past disadvantage experienced by women, Acting Justice Stephen Marshall said in his ruling. 

"(The lounge's) intention was to promote equal opportunity by drawing attention to present and past societal disadvantage to women by providing them with the concept of a 'flipped universe'," he said.

"(It provides) women with a rare glimpse of what it is like to be advantaged rather than disadvantaged." 

The tribunal also failed to properly consider a "report card" on the status of women in 2024 in Australia, which referenced current structural discrimination, Justice Marshall said.

Kirsha Kaechele and other women outside court
The tribunal wrongly found disadvantage experienced by women was in the past, the judge said. (Ethan James/AAP PHOTOS)

The report card found women remained more likely to earn less than men, do more unpaid work, and were more likely to experience sexual violence and abuse. 

During the court hearing, Mr Lau's lawyer Greg Barns SC argued the lounge's purpose was solely to reflect on historical disadvantage.

If the lounge was found to not be discriminatory it followed that you could cordon off areas "to make a point", he said. 

The lounge was enclosed by a curtain and supervised by an attendant who only permitted entry to people who identified as female.

Ms Kaechele has previously flagged trying to find a loophole to reopen the space as a "church", "bathroom" or place of "education" to be exempt from discrimination laws.

Justice Marshall noted the lounge was a participatory installation. 

"The process of being admitted or refused admission and the participation in the ladies' lounge is part of the art itself," he said.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.