An Idaho judge overseeing the case against student murders suspect Bryan Kohberger has decided to release a redacted transcript from a closed-door hearing held last week. Initially closed to the public and media, Ada County Judge Steven Hippler has ordered the release of the transcript after allowing both the prosecution and defense to recommend redactions.
The closed hearing on Jan. 23 focused on forensic investigative genetic genealogy (IGG) evidence that Kohberger's defense team is seeking to exclude. During a subsequent public proceeding, Kohberger's lawyers argued that the FBI's use of IGG techniques violated his Fourth Amendment rights against unreasonable searches and seizures.
Judge Hippler appeared skeptical of the defense's arguments, questioning whether Kohberger had standing to challenge the investigatory tactic. He noted that the DNA in question belonged to Kohberger's ancestors rather than the defendant himself.
The defense also raised concerns about the FBI's adherence to internal policies regarding IGG sample checks against databases. Prosecutors countered by asserting that there is no expectation of privacy in connection with public records and crime scene evidence.
The unredacted transcript could shed light on how investigators built their case following the murders of four students during a home invasion near the University of Idaho. Kohberger, a former Ph.D. student at Washington State University, faces trial later this year and could potentially receive the death penalty if convicted.
Following Kohberger's arraignment in May 2023, a change of venue was granted, moving the case to Ada County under Judge Hippler's jurisdiction. The defense is awaiting a decision on a potential Franks hearing to challenge warrants in the case, a rare legal procedure that experts say is seldom granted and even less frequently successful.
