Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Glasgow Live
Glasgow Live
Sport
Ben Banks

John McGinn Celtic transfer miss revisited as Brendan Rodgers 'wasn't convinced' claim made

Celtic interest in John McGinn has been revisited ahead of the Aston Villa midfielder's 50th cap for Scotland.

The midfielder is set to enter the nation's footballing Hall of Fame when he stands in as captain for tonight's match against Republic of Ireland at Hampden. He moved to the Villans in 2018 and Steven Gerrard has named him as captain, but Celtic tried and failed to snap him up four summer transfer windows ago while Brendan Rodgers was manager.

It's on the mind of Hoops hero Peter Grant, who has debated the failed transfer on Sportsound with another ex-Parkhead star, John Collins. He asked the former Hibs manager: "People talk about the Celtic scenario and them missing out on John. That was always my worry for John when Brendan was there, that Brendan Rodgers didn't push the boat out as he didn't think he was technically good enough to play in his side.

"So it wasn't the fact that Celtic didn't want him, it was maybe the fact Brendan perhaps thought he'd slow the game down or technically wasn't as good. Do you think that's maybe one of the reason they never pushed the boat out on him?"

READ MORE: Tom Rogic's Celtic exit reasons explained by Ange Postecoglou as playmaker labelled Hoops 'legend'

Sign up to Glasgow Live newsletter for more headlines straight to your inbox

Collins replied: "I would like to think Brendan really wanted him. You had Scott Brown at that stage and Callum McGregor.

"Would he have knocked Scott Brown, Callum McGregor out the team? The answer is probably no at that time. Brendan's probably made the decision that he would like him, but not desperate for him."

Grant responded: "I think it's made him grow as a young man having that opportunity to go away (to England). But I felt at that time, Brendan wasn't really convinced John could improve his midfield from the technical point of view."

And Collins wants answers on Rodgers' theorised assessment: "It would be interesting if journalists asked Brendan about John. It'd be nice to hear what he thought about him."

READ NEXT

- The staggering Celtic transfer fees confirmed as Hoops go all out for Carter-Vickers and Jota

- Ian Bankier's Celtic financial address in full including player sales, transfers and pre-tax profit

- Celtic Park and Ibrox facing Euro 2028 omission as Scotland set for one stadium in joint UK bid

- Aaron Mooy to give Celtic Guus Hiddink tips as midfielder spotted with legendary manager Down Under

- Ange Postecoglou 'living the dream' at Celtic as he quashes English Premier League exit talk

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.