An Indiana man convicted in the 2017 killings of two teenage girls has been sentenced to 130 years in prison – the maximum term the trial judge was able to impose.
Richard Allen, 52, was convicted last month in the murder of best friends Abigail Williams, 13, and Liberty German, 14, in the small town of Delphi, close to eight years after the children’s bodies were found near a hiking trail.
The murders shocked America and went for a long time without a breakthrough in finding the killer. State police arrested Allen in October 2022 after what authorities described as a “long-term and complex investigation” that determined Allen encountered the girls on a trail and, armed with a gun, forced them down a hill and cut their throats.
After Allen received the maximum sentence, Judge Frances Gull told him it ranks “right up there with the most hideous crimes”.
“These families will deal with your carnage forever,” the judge added.
Allen, who worked at the local CVS pharmacy, had pleaded not guilty to the killings and his lawyers claimed the murders were part of a ritual sacrifice. In a sentencing memorandum, his defense said Allen had a long history of mental health illness.
Allen was not a suspected of the killings until 2022 when a filing clerk organizing thousands of tips discovered a “lead sheet” showing that Allen had reached out to investigators soon after the killings, saying he’d been at the hiking trail on the day of the murders, had been incorrectly marked “clear”.
But a trail of evidence had long pointed to Allen. One of the victims had recorded a man who prosecutors alleged was Allen in cellphone video that day.
An unspent .40-caliber round that came from Allen’s gun was found at the scene and a black 2016 Ford Focus was seen on security video nearby. Allen owned the only car of that kind registered in the county when the murders occurred.
In court, prosecutors played a jail phone recording of Allen to his wife they said amounted to a confession. In it, Allen said: “I did it, I killed Abby. I killed Abby and Libby.”
However, his wife did not appear to believe him and said his medication must be messing with his mind. A prison psychologist also testified at trial that Allen confessed to her that he had killed the girls.
