Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - AU
The Guardian - AU
Lifestyle
Eleanor Gordon-Smith

I have terminal cancer. I fear dying and leaving my daughter with my husband. What can I do?

Auguste Toulmouche - Consolation 1867.
‘How do I get my husband to “grow up” to ensure our daughter’s future?’ Painting: Consolation by Auguste Toulmouche, 1867. Photograph: Artefact/Alamy

I was diagnosed with terminal lung cancer three years ago, when my only child, a daughter, was eight. My cancer was discovered too late for a cure, ironically because I was in very good shape, a non-smoker, and otherwise in good health and a dedicated exerciser.

I will probably die within the next few years – I was initially given less than two years to live but have bucked the prognosis for now. I am in a treatment that has very severe side effects, key of which is extreme fatigue. Nonetheless, I try to make the best of it and exercise almost every day as a way to counteract the pain and fatigue.

My issue is my husband. He drinks excessively and has never exercised. Since the diagnosis, these issues have gotten worse to the point where he quit his job and spends most of his days on the internet. He refuses to take better care of himself, although he has tried to quit drinking multiple times to no avail. He is grumpy, depressed and very unpleasant to be around, not to mention a very bad example for our daughter. He is often very impatient with her and very short tempered. I am scared for her and any time I bring this up, he gets angry. Financially we are OK as I have a good disability plan and good insurance, but I worry for him and her future with him.

I fear dying and leaving her with this man. What can I do? If he is acting this way now, what will he do when my disease progresses to the point where I can’t function at such a high level (I currently do the majority of the household chores)? How do I get him to “grow up” and start taking better care of himself to ensure our daughter’s future?

Eleanor says: I am so sorry for what you have to bear. I am sorry for your pain, for your grief in missing what you’ve looked forward to, and most especially that you have to endure this without enough help from the person who should be your closest ally.

In answering your question, I wanted to speak to some grief counsellors to make sure you had their expertise. They said it sounds like your husband may be not processing his own grief terribly well – that alcohol, games or abandoning housework may be his way of retreating from the reality of your diagnosis. Many of us avoid thinking about death our whole lives because to do so risks total ruination; we pull away from friends who are bereaved or ill because we need the illusion of immortality to function. It may be that your husband’s slackness and irritability aren’t failures to realise what rests on his shoulders now but responses to realising it all too well. He may fear he’ll be crushed under its weight.

Your question was about how to influence him – “how do I get him to grow up?”

If his behaviour at the moment is a response to grief – depression or avoidance – then growing up may not be something you can make him do. You cannot lever him into the humility and commitment that real change requires; or into the realisation that however painful it is to face death, it will be less painful than the damage he may otherwise do. All you can do is bravely and candidly say what you have said to me – and it may be that as long as you don’t tell him this truth, he will not change. But this does not guarantee that he will change once you do.

So, if you’ll permit me, I think there is an equally pressing question alongside how to make him grow up – “What do I do if he won’t?”

Sometimes we ask for advice because we’re hoping that someone else will be able to see something in our situation that we haven’t; a concealed nook or passageway that gives us a way out without a painful conflict. But in this extraordinarily difficult situation, I think there’s no secret nook. The options are that he changes or that he doesn’t. If he doesn’t – you say you feel scared for your child. That is a terrible feeling. You say you fear leaving her “with this man”.

There will come a moment when you have to decide whether he has earned your trust to parent your only and beloved daughter. If he has not, the solution will be legal, custodial, and found with the help of your daughter and your family. You may need to seriously consider formalising a role for godparents, siblings, grandparents or other trusted adults in your daughter’s life, or leaving clear and written instructions to her about what she should not tolerate.

Try not to put off thinking through those possibilities because you are occupied with the hope that you can change your husband. You have already fronted up to some seriously tough realities, from the necessity of punishing treatments to the stony brutishness of insurance. If your husband is not able to be the father you need him to be, your bravery in facing that reality could be a shining gift to your daughter.

As anyone who has lost a loving parent knows, death need not divide us from a parent’s love. The world you leave for her can envelop her in your love, even when you cannot.

Ask us a question

Do you have a conflict, crossroads or dilemma you need help with? Eleanor Gordon-Smith will help you think through life’s questions and puzzles, big and small. Questions can be anonymous.

  • If you’re having trouble using the form, click here. Read terms of service here

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.