Re Simon Jenkins’ article (For a bird’s eye view of British conservatism, look at sport. No wonder VAR in football is in trouble, 16 May), I think I could claim to be first to use video to record a disputed offside decision.
On 22 September 1973, Bristol City was at home to Sheffield Wednesday. In my role as manager of Rediffusion’s Bristol Channel, a small new community television station, I had been invited by City to show the possible use of video in training.
Trying out different places to record, by chance I was exactly opposite the incident. The linesman’s flag stayed down and City’s Keith Fear went on to score.
It was not until afterwards that I saw what my camera had captured. The decision was right: goal. In the crowded club office after the match, I replayed the tape to repeated requests – from both teams and their managers, then the linesman and the referee, then the referee’s assessor – and finally the Bristol Evening Post, which normally ignored our station.
For them, a replay was on the condition that their report properly named us. Monday’s paper honoured the deal, their report headlined “TV proves it – Fear goal was onside”.
Prof Peter Lewis
London Metropolitan University
• Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
