Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
South China Morning Post
South China Morning Post
Lifestyle
Elaine Yau

‘God blesses stupid children too’: Chinese reality-show star Yang Chaoyue has final message for her many critics and fans

The Chinese singer was called a “drag on her team” when she took part in a TV talent show and landed a spot in a pop group – but Yang Chaoyue is now shaking off her critics with a promising acting career.

At the recent swansong performance of Chinese pop group Rocket Girls 101, all eyes were on Yang Chaoyue.

Ever since the 11-member group was formed in 2018 from finalists in the Chinese edition of the talent show

Produce 101
, the singer has been the one that has had the most media attention. The focus, though, has not been her talent – but on her lack of it.

One particularly memorable moment was when Yang sang a cappella on stage during the televised competition and when she broke down in tears during and after her lacklustre performance. She was criticised for her poor singing and dancing skills by judges and online commentators throughout the show.

Despite this, the singer garnered more than 130 million votes from members of the public in the final – placing her third overall.

Yang took more than 130 million public votes in the final of the talent show Produce 101.

The 21-year-old, dubbed a crybaby by the Chinese media, has been dividing opinions ever since, with critics arguing there were more talented and deserving contestants and that the show sets a bad example for young girls, while Yang’s supporters insist her genuineness makes up for her shortcomings.

Author and entertainment blogger Mi Meng was among Yang’s most scathing critics, saying: “She doesn’t have any ability. She doesn’t work hard and can only cry. She is a huge baby. She is a drag on her team. To all the girls who work hard in the world, her ranking [on the show] is a joke.”

In 2018, Yang was featured on the cover of China Newsweek magazine after being selected as one of the year’s most influential Chinese people.

Some people lodged complaints to China’s Ministry of Culture, with one saying “the acknowledgement of a contestant who can’t sing and dance [in a talent competition] is at odds with core social values, giving the public the impression that solely beauty can bring success”.

Communist Party mouthpiece People's Daily (people.cn) was more generous in its appraisal of Yang in 2018: “Whether it’s singing, dancing or creativity, Yang is not good among the contestants. But she looks pretty and has a very authentic personality … her [rise] is a show of grass-roots power overlooked [in the past].”

Yang comes from a single-parent family in a village in Jiangsu province in eastern China. She quit school to support her farmer father, who told the media in 2018 that his daughter often cried because she was unable to see the world. “I don’t have money to send her to school to learn dancing and singing. She cries because she gets nervous easily,” he said.

It’s a story that has made her fans love her even more. In 2018, Yang was featured on the cover of China Newsweek after being selected as one of the year’s most influential Chinese people, alongside the likes of physicist Wang Yifang and economist Zhu Min.

In 2018, Yang was often criticised for crying and for performing poorly on Produce 101. Photo: Visual China Group via Getty Images

During Rocket Girls 101’s farewell show on June 23, Yang delivered a tear-filled speech, saying: “I can’t do anything well. I am [only] good at arguing with my boss … But God doesn’t just like clever people. He blesses stupid children like us, too. So don’t give up on yourself [even if] you are mediocre and stupid.”

Now that her obligations to the girl group have come to an end, Yang has set up a talent management agency. She wants to focus on her acting – which, unlike her singing and dancing, has not been panned by her usual critics. indeed, her supporting role in period drama series Ever Night 2 surpassed expectations.

She will play the lead in two upcoming TV shows: romance drama series Midsummer is Full of Hearts and period drama series Dance of the Phoenix. Her fans are waiting to see whether she can finally carve out an illustrious show business career.

Recommended for you

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.