The New York Giants designated quarterback Tyrod Taylor to return from injured reserve (IR) on Monday and expectations are that he’ll be active in Week 14 against the Green Bay Packers.
That puts head coach Brian Daboll in somewhat of a precarious position.
The Giants have gone 2-1 in Tommy DeVito’s three starts and the rookie is now the toast of the town. He’s become a national sensation and earned the respect and trust of his teammates.
Still, there’s no denying that Taylor’s skillset gives the Giants a better chance to win. And that’s not a knock on DeVito, it’s just a credit to Taylor.
So, what are the Giants to do? Technically still in the NFC Playoff hunt, do they go with Taylor, who is likely to depart via free agency this coming offseason, or DeVito, who could use the added NFL experience?
Whatever decision Daboll makes, his players will support it.
“Obviously, Tyrod, the veteran presence. He’s been in the league I think it’s 13 years. DeVito brings in energy, juice. He’s still learning the game and that works out for him,” left tackle Andrew Thomas said. “So they’re different guys, but we trust both of those guys. Whatever the coaches decide, that’s what we’ll go with and we’re going to protect the same and we’re going to block the same regardless of who’s back there.”
Although there wasn’t a single Giants player willing to put a stamp on either Taylor or DeVito, it was clear that the former’s NFL experience looms large.
“Tyrod has been in the league for 12 years, something like that and DeVito is a rookie. There’s a lot of things that Tyrod knows about the game and kind of more so like the way he carries himself,” wide receiver Darius Slayton said. “Everybody kind of has to learn how to carry themselves — like how you fit into a team as you grow in this league and as a rookie, especially a quarterback, a leadership position, you have to kind of find your way.
“I feel like DeVito’s done a good job of finding his way quickly, but it’s impossible to close a gap of 12 years. I think DeVito’s done a great job and Tyrod’s a professional, that’s why he’s been in this league so long. I’m glad to have both on our team.”
With five games remaining, Daboll’s quarterback decision will be telling. If he chooses Taylor, that will mean the Giants are gunning for a sneaky playoff spot. If he chooses DeVito, that likely indicates he’s already looking ahead to next year.
Follow the Giants Wire Podcast:
Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Google Podcasts
