Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
ABC News
ABC News
Health
Paige Cockburn 

Fitness empire F45 loses court battle to stop rival gym using workout technology

The F45 fitness empire has failed in a bid to prevent a rival chain from using computerised fitness programs.  (Supplied: F45)

F45 is a multi-billion-dollar Australian success story that's gone global, but a court has ordered the fitness behemoth to share its recipe for success.

A battle between rival gym empires has ended in a major loss for F45, which had accused a competitor of copying its workout technology.

F45 — which has more than 1,750 franchises in 45 countries — took Body Fit Training to the Federal Court, claiming the Melbourne-based enterprise had infringed a patent it had on its electronic coaching system.

In court, F45 claimed the system produced tangible results for clients and, consequently, economic success for the financial empire.

Its lawyers argued that Body Fit Training had copied the scheme by also configuring their fitness studios from a central server.

F45's system uses a computer network to disseminate exercise routines to all of its studios, which gym-goers then watch on screens as they work out.

The fitness chain has set out to modernise the traditional gym format. (Supplied: F45 Training Hastings)

But yesterday, F45 suffered a double blow in the Federal Court.

Justice John Nicholas ruled that Body Fit had not infringed F45's patent and that the patent was invalid and should be revoked.

F45 has also been ordered to pay Body Fit Training's costs.

Justice Nicholas said the business scheme was not patentable "merely because it is implemented using generic computing technology."

American actor Mark Wahlberg is one of the financial backers of the F45 fitness empire.  (Supplied)

F45, which was founded in 2013, has star-studded backers, including US actor Mark Wahlberg, former golfer Greg Norman and supermodel Cindy Crawford.

The company aimed to modernise the traditional gym format and last year made its market debut on Wall Street with a $2 billion valuation.

However, Body Fit Training has had a rapid rise in the Australian fitness industry and has caught the attention of high-profile athletes, with franchises bought by former Test cricketers Tim Paine and George Bailey, and former AFL star Nick Riewoldt.

Dr Kayleen Manwaring, an intellectual property expert at the University of NSW, said attempting to make a computer system exclusive was a big ask.

"It's still a contested area of law and there have been a series of cases knocking down business schemes," she said.

The gym chain has brought  similar legal action in the United States.  (ABC News: Herlyn Kaur)

F45 currently has a similar patent case before the courts in the United States.

Dr Manwaring said losing the case in Australia did not mean the company's US suit was doomed to fail.

"There is a different set of principles that apply in the US, so F45 may win in the US," she said.

In Australia, though, she warned, this case may make it harder to get similar technological patents approved. 

Body Fit Training's co-chief executives, Cameron Falloon and Richard Burnet, have previously said they were not going to let F45 push them out of the marketplace.

They said F45 was trying to assert "invalid patents" to try and hinder "what we believe to be a superior business model and approach to fitness training".

In a statement issued to the ABC, Mr Falloon and Mr Burnet said they were "thrilled" the court ruled in their favour.

"We look forward to continuing to offer a different and better product, as Australia's fastest growing fitness franchise," the pair said.

F45 says a core part of its business is protecting its innovations and its founder and chief executive, Rob Deutsch, has previously boasted about its methods and techniques being patent- protected.

The ABC has approached F45 for comment.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.