Just before Joe Biden leaves the White House and Donald Trump returns, two prominent Republican members of the Federal Reserve Board are weighing in on how fast interest rates should come down.
The two—Michelle Bowman and Christopher Waller—say rates can come down in a measured way as long as there's more progress in bringing inflation down to the Fed's goal of 2% a year.
Related: Analysts reboot Amazon stock price targets on AWS, RTO updates
The minutes of the Fed's Dec. 17-18 meeting, released on Jan. 8, show that both are firmly in the camp of not hurrying.
The two offered their views in speeches this week. Bowman spoke Jan. 9 at a California Bankers Association meeting in Laguna Beach, Calif. Waller's remarks came Jan. 8 in Paris at a meeting of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.
Both voted for the Fed's December decision to trim its key short-term Federal Funds Rate to a range of 4.25% to 4.5%. In summer 2023, the rate was 5.25% to 5.5%.
However, long-term bond yields increased as the Fed cut the Federal Funds Rates.
Bowman notably dissented on the Fed's September rate-cut decision (to 4.75% to 5%), its first rate cut since 2000.
That dissent was the first in any Fed rate decision in 20 years. Bowman worried that the September rate cut was too big and risked reigniting inflation.
Waller had been comfortable about cutting rates in September (and the two since) because he says some inflation measures don't measure actual prices but impute prices and thus overstate the inflation reality.
Related: Popular retail CEO delivers blunt words about key Amazon business
Two ways of looking at Fed interest rate cuts
That said, both Fed governors believe rates can come down if the data support the idea.
Waller may be more confident that more cuts are ahead, perhaps because his perspective comes from years working in the Federal Reserve system. He was executive vice president of the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis and helped turn the bank's data repository—Federal Reserve Economic Data or FRED—into an internationally known economic resource.
Bowman is a bit more cautious. She spent several years working at a small Kansas bank her family has owned for more than 140 years before being tapped to be Kansas Banking Commissioner.
She is laser-focused on inflation stickiness. Inflation has come down to 2.6% to 3% from highs seen in 2022. But for Bowman, 2% is the goal.
And she told the California group, "Given the lack of continued progress on lowering inflation and the ongoing strength in economic activity and in the labor market, I could have supported taking no action at the December meeting."
Plus, she worries about the near-term future, especially geopolitical stresses and supply-chain disruptions. (A longshoremen's strike that could have crippled ports on the East and Gulf Coasts was averted on Jan. 8 with a new six-year contract.)
Bowman's and Waller's views can be seen in the Fed's December meeting minutes, especially when the 2% goal is achieved.
"Several (of the meeting participants) observed that the disinflationary process may have stalled temporarily or noted the risk that it could," the minutes said. "A couple of participants judged that positive sentiment in financial markets and momentum in economic activity could continue to put upward pressure on inflation."
The conclusion: "The process (of getting inflation to 2%) could take longer than previously anticipated."
Donald Trump nominated her and Waller as Fed governors. Bowman is touted as a successor to Michael Barr as vice chair for supervision. She believes in flexible regulation that matches the need. Small banks' rules don't apply to large banks like Citigroup (C) , Wells Fargo (WFC) , and Bank of America (BAC) , she says.
The banking industry was thrilled that Barr will step aside on Feb. 28. He will remain a governor, however. Trump gets to nominate Barr's successor, who must be a Republican.
More Economic Analysis:
- Fed interest rate cut bets in 2025 tied to Trump policy wild cards
- Inflation report adds to interest rate cut bet complexity
- Trump's plans will test Fed interest rate cut bets in 2025
Markets are still looking uneasy
What, you ask, are they talking about? Here are three indicators that feed into the question:
- The 10-year bond yield was 4.71% on Jan. 8, up from 4.69% on Jan. 7 and 3.62% in September before the Fed's first rate cut.
- Rates on 30-year mortgages on Jan. 8 were right around 7%. There's hope in real estate circles that sooner or later buyers will just accept rates much higher than 2021 and 2022 and start buying.
- Gasoline prices have risen since late December and are up 0.9% so far in January.
The minutes were released in mid-afternoon on Jan. 8, a day when stocks moved modestly higher at best. The Standard & Poor's 500 Index was up 0.2% to 5,918, and the Dow Jones Industrial Average added 107 points to 42,635.
The Nasdaq Composite slipped slightly to 19,479. The three averages have barely moved since Dec. 31, evidence that the post-election rally is losing its froth.
U.S. stock markets were closed on Jan. 9 for former President Jimmy Carter's state funeral in Washington.
Related: Veteran fund manager issues dire S&P 500 warning for 2025
