Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - AU
The Guardian - AU
Sport
Robert Kitson in Tokyo

Borthwick’s England vision taking shape as Marcus Smith gets leading role

Marcus Smith and Fin Smith shake hands during an England training session in Urayasu, Chiba, Japan
Marcus Smith (left) will start for England ahead of fellow fly-half Fin Smith in the Test against Japan. Photograph: Koki Nagahama/RFU/The RFU Collection/Getty Images

In the past 24 hours there has been an estimated eight inches of torrential rain fall in the Tokyo region, but ­England are determined to shine brightly against Japan this Saturday. Steve Borthwick wants his team to trust their attacking instincts against Eddie Jones’s Japan and the choice of Marcus Smith at fly-half and a first start for Chandler ­Cunningham‑South in the back row reflects the proactive mood.

Rather than waiting until Thursday to name his side as scheduled, the England head coach opted to push forward the announcement by 48 hours, the kind of pre-emptive curveball often thrown by Jones on occasions in the past. Arguably most striking of all, though, is Borthwick’s desire for his players to maintain the momentum they were building in the latter half of the Six Nations, with Smith handed the baton as chief playmaker.

The 25-year-old Harlequin player will regard this as an opportunity that needs to be grasped, with ­Borthwick having chosen to back him rather than give a first Test start to his Northampton namesake Fin Smith. England have relied previously on the experienced Owen Farrell or George Ford to set the tactical tone and, with the latter now unavailable through injury and Farrell ­heading to France, there had been some ­speculation the younger Smith might be fast-tracked.

Instead the effervescent Quins No 10 has been given the nod and invited to stake an unanswerable claim before the two-Test series in New Zealand next month. Until injury struck in January he had been poised to be England’s first-choice fly‑half in the Six Nations but it was Ford who eventually took the reins.

It underlines England’s commitment to the quicker, more attacking brand of rugby that is fast becoming their preferred modus operandi, albeit with a continuing emphasis on getting the basics right at the breakdown and at the set-pieces.

“What is important is that we go on to the pitch on Saturday and play the way we have been building over this last few months,” Borthwick said.

“We showed some growth through the Six Nations and now we wish to take the next step. We have a young squad full of talent and exciting ­players. What I say to them every day is to bring their point of dif­ference on to the pitch.”

It is equally clear, though, that Borthwick’s vision of England’s medium‑term future is taking real shape. Already he has taken a decisive call at full-back, where George ­Furbank has edged past Freddie ­Steward, and backed form ­Premiership players such as Alex Mitchell and Henry Slade, neither of whom were part of his original World Cup selection. He is clearly now ­hoping that investing a little faith in Smith will unlock the obvious ability that, to date, has been per­mitted to flower at Test level only in fits and starts.

England starting XV v Japan on Saturday: G Furbank; I Feyi-Waboso, H Slade, O Lawrence, T Freeman; M Smith, A Mitchell; B Rodd, J George (capt), D Cole, M Itoje, G Martin, C Cunningham-South, S Underhill, B Earl.

Replacements: T Dan, J Marler, W Stuart, C Ewels, T Curry, H Randall, F Smith, T Roebuck.

“From the first moment he walked into camp I sensed an even greater determination and hunger than I’ve ever seen in Marcus,” Borthwick said. “As a player Marcus has more line breaks per game than any other fly‑half in the Premiership. I rate ­Marcus exceptionally highly and I feel very privileged as a coach to have both Marcus and Fin in this squad.”

The starting XV shows a total of four changes from the team’s last game against France in Lyon in March. Cunningham‑South, a power­ful ball-carrier with a big future, replaces the injured Ollie Chessum at blindside flanker while Sale’s Bevan Rodd fills the front-row hole left by another pre-tour casualty Ellis Genge. In addition to Smith’s return at fly‑half, Immanuel Feyi-Waboso is back on the wing having missed the France game.

Warren Gatland accepts that Wales' backs are against the wall as they prepare to tackle world champions South Africa at Twickenham on Saturday. However, the Wales head coach believes players have a chance "to step up" after seeing his selection hand forced by injuries and unavailability.

The latest injury blow came with flanker Jac Morgan (pictured) being ruled out of the Springboks clash and summer tour to Australia. Morgan, who was Wales' World Cup co-captain with Dewi Lake last year, missed this season's Six Nations because of a knee injury. He now has a hamstring problem and has been released from the squad.

Wales are also without several England-based players because Saturday's game falls outside World Rugby's summer Test window and means they cannot be considered for selection. They have also been badly hit in the second-row department, with Six Nations captain Jenkins and his Exeter colleague Christ Tshiunza both unavailable, Will Rowlands being rested and Adam Beard injured.

"We have our backs to the wall a little bit this week, but we are really excited about the challenge," Gatland said. "I see it as a great opportunity for other players to step up and put their hands up.

"I look back at my own experience as a young player coming through and playing against Auckland, who were one of the best teams in the world and full of All Blacks. As a young Waikato player they put 40 points on us, and the amount I learnt as a player was part of my growth and development."

Hooker Lake, who also sat out the Six Nations due to injury, will be captain against South Africa, with James Botham wearing the No 7 shirt and lining up in a back-row that also includes Taine Plumtree and Aaron Wainwright.

Cardiff scrum-half Ellis Bevan is handed a Test debut, while Liam Williams makes a first Wales appearance since the 2023 World Cup.

There are three uncapped players on the bench, meanwhile, in Ospreys forward James Ratti, Scarlets centre Eddie James and Cardiff back Jacob Beetham.

World champions South Africa have named uncapped Jordan Hendrikse at fly-half and Edwill van der Merwe on the wing in a much-changed squad, with Pieter-Steph du Toit to lead the side. Flanker Ben-Jason Dixon and utility back Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu are also likely to make their debuts off the bench as coach Rassie Erasmus opts for a 5-3 split between forwards and backs among the replacements. Agencies 

The matchday squad will also include the return on the bench of Tom Curry, who has not featured for England since the World Cup because of a hip problem which necessitated surgery. His uncapped clubmate Tom Roebuck is in line for a debut as a replacement, with Bath’s Charlie Ewels and Bristol’s Harry Randall also recalled on the bench.

“This is an important next step as a team,” said Borthwick, who was part of Japan’s coaching staff during Jones’s first spell in charge. One of his fondest memories with the Brave Blossoms was a beach mauling session which spilled over into the sea – “We ended up going into slightly deeper water where one or two ­players didn’t feel comfortable” – and he is relishing being back in Tokyo. He will enjoy it even more if the weather dries up and England can dazzle on Saturday.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.