Eagle-eyed Emmerdale viewers think they have worked out the real identity of Reuben's dad after an actor let slip a huge clue.
Fans are convinced Mackenzie Boyd (Lawrence Robb) isn't the real father, after the pair had a one night stand. Since the night, Mackenzie split with Charity Dingle to try and make the family work - but all may not be as it seems.
Some Emmerdale fans have taken to Twitter with a theory that Nate Robinson (Jurell Carter) could be Reuben's dad following a previous fling. Nate recently tied the knot with Tracy Metcalfe (Amy Walsh) on the soap last week.
READ MORE: Emmerdale's Wendy Posner star's admission on tragic loss and phone call that saved career
The Express reported that Jurell said: "I think obviously he’s had a fling with Chloe. That was just a sexual thing rather than any kind of romance or anything like that.
"He met Naomi, which they got on, but again, work commitments and just not being on the same page got in the way.
"So I think he's finally got his match with Tracy and I feel like it's nice to see on screen as well."
Fans took to Twitter to share their thoughts, one said: "#Emmerdale After all this, Nate will be the baby’s father!"
A second fan said: "#emmerdale is Mack really the father? Didn't she sleep with Nate too? Al?"
A third tweet read: "If the baby somehow ended up being Nate's, Ruben would go from being Moira's nephew to Cain's grandson #Emmerdale."
Receive newsletters with the biggest and breaking TV and showbiz news by signing up here
For more celeb news, videos and pictures follow our designated Facebook page HERE
