Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
Lifestyle
Zoe Williams

Dining across the divide: ‘She worried that 16- to 25-year-olds don’t have the maturity to make life-changing decisions’

Teresa (left) and Lyn
Teresa (left) and Lyn. All photographs: Andrew Hasson/The Guardian Photograph: Andrew Hasson/The Guardian

Teresa, 75, Hailsham, East Sussex

Teresa

Occupation Retired

Voting record Usually Lib Dem. Doesn’t vote Labour because she has always lived in an area where the contest is between the Conservatives and the Lib Dems

Amuse bouche At 19, she bought an old taxi for £15. On the way home, the guy in the petrol station asked how much she had paid. He said: “That’s a good buy – goodbye to 15 quid

Lyn, 68, London

Lyn

Occupation Retired social worker

Voting record Usually Labour. The odd Green and Lib Dem vote, but never Tory

Amuse bouche Had an infestation of giant flying ants in her kitchen, and the massacre was hideous to watch

For starters

Lyn I had the fresh pasta with asparagus and mascarpone. Then we had a tube with ricotta in it, with orange and dark chocolate flavouring.

Teresa I had sea bass fillets with what they called small prawns, though they looked like shrimps to me, with a butter and lemon sauce. Delicious, it was.

Lyn I’d been told that she was trans. My first impression was: I would never have known. I actually questioned it. She was completely feminine. It’s awful that we make these judgments.

Teresa We got on well. She was very welcoming, a very pleasant individual.

Teresa and Lyn

The big beef

Teresa She indicated that she was concerned about the proposed changes to the gender recognition act in Scotland, but not the usual concerns. She said she was worried about 16- to 25-year-olds not having the maturity to make life-changing decisions. I thought it was illogical because we already have arbitrary age limits for all kinds of important decisions.

Lyn I’d read up on the Scottish bill before it was blocked by the UK government, and seen that from 16 people would be allowed to live as the gender they wanted to be, and after six months they could get a birth certificate – they would be recognised as that gender. There weren’t any safeguards, protection for vulnerable people.

Teresa She was coming at it from a protection side. I said there was another side: children whose parents aren’t supportive, who do have gender dysphoria. One of the problems with gender recognition applications is that you still need a diagnosis, from a psychiatrist, of a condition that is no longer recognised as a psychiatric condition. So the whole thing is nonsense. The only person who can diagnose whether a person has gender dysphoria is the person themselves.

Lyn Self-certification at 16 is too young. I think Teresa agreed with me, though I’ve got to say my hearing is not great and her voice was quite soft.

Teresa and Lyn

Sharing plate

Teresa We had a long conversation about bereavement, because I’d lost my partner a few years ago. And the same thing had happened with her husband. She was obviously in agreement that the NHS isn’t adequately funded.

Lyn We had very different experiences. My husband was a very fit man, he worked in the construction industry, he’d never been ill, he was robust, a big man, a strong person – he’d pick up a washing machine. He died very suddenly. I found him in the garden. It was an awful, awful shock. He was 72. Why I didn’t think he’d ever die, I don’t know, but it never crossed my mind.

Teresa My late partner had lung cancer, but they never did find out what the primary site had been because it developed so quickly. She went downhill so fast. I nursed her at home as long as I could. Lyn was obviously very sympathetic about that.

Lyn She was absolutely lovely. A very empathic, kind, nice person.

Teresa and Lyn

For afters

Teresa I voted remain and I’m still a remainer. Or a rejoiner. She said she had been a Brexiter, but had since changed her mind. So I thought: that’s kind of killed that conversation.

Lyn I voted Brexit, and my daughter is always on my case, going: “Mum, how could you?” And both my sons: “Oh, Mother.” And I just say: “I’m entitled to my own opinion.” But my opinion has changed. I think there have been consequences all over the place. I’m staggered by this current government.

Teresa and Lyn

Takeaways

Teresa It was a very enjoyable experience. She texted afterwards, and I texted her back, saying I was a bit concerned that we hadn’t covered enough ground. She said: “We could just claim Alzheimer’s.”

Lyn That was one lovely lunch we had. And it was a beautiful restaurant. In the middle of Crawley, of all places!

Teresa (left) and Lyn

Additional reporting: Kitty Drake.

• Lyn and Teresa ate at Da Nico in Crawley

Want to meet someone from across the divide? Find out how to take part

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.