Plans to knock down a row of derelict garages in Portobello to make way for two family homes have been given the go ahead.
Edinburgh city councillors granted planning permission despite 40 local objections, after they visited the small site off East Brighton Crescent.
However the proposals were not backed by all members of the planning sub-committee this week with one saying he feared it would 'cram too much into a very limited space.'
READ MORE: Edinburgh millionaire mansion gets go ahead despite neighbours being 'up in arms'
Residents also complained the new homes - described by one councillor as being "extremely attractive" - would be out of keeping with the Portobello conservation area and would overshadow neighbouring properties and invade privacy.
The existing four lock-up garages, situated at the end of Lee Crescent, will be demolished as the site is cleared for two semi-detached three-bed houses, both of which will have back gardens.
Work will also involve repositioning and rebuilding of the existing rear listed garden wall.
Planners said: "The two new houses will be one and a half storeys in height and of a contemporary design.
"The proposal will result in the creation of a satisfactory residential environment and will not have a detrimental impact on the amenity of neighbouring residents and setting of the listed building."
However, one objector argued the plans would result in "over-development" of the site.
They said: "The existing garages are not visually intrusive and are appropriate in scale and form. The creation of two, 2-storey dwellings is over ambitious for this site."
Another called it "visually intrusive," adding: "It overlooks the gardens of 2/3 East Brighton Crescent, impacting their privacy. The proposed garden is too small and keeps light out of the ground floor living areas."
It was also feared that having no parking spaces for the homes would result in added pressure to "already congested" surrounding residential streets.
Following a site visit last week plans went before councillors at the City Chambers on Wednesday (February 8).
Jo Mowat, Conservatives, praised the houses for being "extremely attractive and good use of space."
The SNP's Amy McNeese-Mechan said: "We're not looking at the conversion of a listed building, we've got some not particularly attractive and probably not particularly useful lock-ups there that are going to become family homes, although I appreciate people right now may be concerned about the change."
Planning sub-committee member Tim Jones, who is also local Conservative councillor for Portobello, said he was concerned the redevelopment would be "cramming too much into a very limited space."
He added: "The problems regarding the impact in terms of noise, privacy - it's very difficult to come down one side or the other on this.
"I do have quite serious reservations about this. I just feel it's crammed into too small a space."
The committee granted full planning permission and listed building consent with councillor Jones noting his dissent.
READ NEXT:
- Edinburgh Airport car parking prices from short and long stay to drop off and fast track
- Edinburgh cocktail bar owner took part in police chase after undercover cop sting
- Edinburgh to slash roads repair budget as North Bridge costs rise by £24m
- Edinburgh taxi fares to rise by 20%, with a two-mile trip set to cost almost £10
- Edinburgh strip club ban could be scrapped as council agree to review 'unsafe' policy
