Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
ABC News
ABC News
Business

Cyclone Debbie just the beginning for Queensland family battling CommInsure to fix their roof

Pam and Ian Hathaway are still fighting for repairs five years after Cyclone Debbie. (ABC Tropical North: Angel Parsons )

A North Queensland family still fighting for a safe home after a cyclone damaged their roof five years ago say they feel exhausted, "violated and victimised" by their insurer.

Ian and Pam Hathaway have spent countless hours writing emails, sleeping on the floor, and flinching every time a light storm rolled by because they were afraid the damaged roof would lift off.

They claim wrong materials were used in one failed roof rebuild and structural rods that protected the house during high winds were severed during a second failed attempt.

Mr Hathaway said that what began as a simple house insurance claim in the wake of Cyclone Debbie has amounted to a situation worse than a "nightmare".

"Cyclone Debbie didn't wreck this house; CommInsure did."

Once a place of pride, joy, love and family, they felt like their Collinsville home had been reduced to a construction site for years and remained an unsafe dwelling.

The couple say they are exhausted after two failed roof rebuilds. (ABC Tropical North: Angel Parsons)

In a statement to the ABC, CommInsure said it understood the repairs were not satisfactory and it was committed to resolving the matter.

But insurance advocate David Keane, who has worked with the family for years, said what the family had gone through was unacceptable.

"Those sorts of cases are not that uncommon, unfortunately."

Trust issues from the start

In the months after 2017's Cyclone Debbie, the Hathaways discovered parts of their roof had been damaged because mould was growing.

A quote from a local builder indicated the works would cost about $188,000, which was significantly higher than CommInsure's original quote of about $60,000. 

CommInsure and its own builder then came back with a revised repair cost of $140,000.

The first roof repair went ahead but, according to Mr Hathaway, the wrong materials were used, including a thinner gauge of iron.

The Hathaways say they had no ceiling for several months between roof rebuilds. (Supplied: Pam Hathaway)

It needed to be done again, leaving the Hathaways' home life disrupted for months. 

"We found where an electrical cable in our bedroom had been squashed between an iron and a screw.

"They did come back and fix that, but we were fortunate that the whole roof was not live."

The Hathaways say this bedroom light wire was squashed between the roof and a batten. (Supplied: Pam and Ian Hathaway)

'Gravity holding roof on'

Things became worse when work started on the second attempt to rebuild the roof.

"I heard a banging, popping noise … like a drum popping in the heat of the day," Mr Hathaway said. 

"The structural tie downs that hold it all together had been cut."

Ian Hathaway says rods that help secure the roof during high wind events were cut in error. (Supplied: Pam Hathaway)

Despite Mr Hathaway's shock and protests, "they just kept cutting" the tension rods, which provide structural integrity and protection against high winds and cyclones.

"Gravity was the only thing holding it on."

That was more than two years ago.

Since then, the Hathaways have been fighting for acknowledgement and action.

Mr Hathaway said the situation had hurt him emotionally, professionally and personally.

"Married over 25 years and some of the arguments we've had over this, shouldn't have happened," Mr Hathaway said. 

"[We feel] violated, victimised — the accusations just don't stop."

Ian and Pam Hathaway's home life remains stressful five years after Cyclone Debbie.  (ABC Tropical North: Angel Parsons)

End in sight

After lodging a complaint with the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC), the couple finally saw some action.

But Mr Keane said the journey was not over yet.

"The builder and CommInsure … said, 'Please call off QBCC and we'll get everything fixed'," Mr Keane said. 

"So in good faith we called off the QBCC complaint, and waited for several months for them to give the scope of works."

CommInsure said it sympathised with Mr Hathaway's situation. 

"Since then we have reopened the claim, undertaken an investigation and a scope of works has been approved to complete the repairs."

Years of fighting for adequate repairs is taking a toll on Ian Hathaway. (ABC Tropical North: Angel Parsons)

Ian Hathaway still feared the company's plans gave no answers as to how to fix the situation with the severed rods.

CommInsure said the works were due to start on April 28 and would be "completed within a few weeks". 

"We will provide alternative accommodation to Mr Hathaway and his family during the entire repair period," a spokesperson said. 

The QBCC said it could not comment on the case for privacy reasons.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.