Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Street
The Street
Laura Rodini

Consumer Reports: Cheapest cars to maintain over 10 years

Malcolm Gladwell may have theorized that it takes 10,000 hours of practice to become an expert at a chosen task, but if you devoted 10,000 hours toward buying your next new car, people would think you’re nuts.

That’s because most smart car buying decisions can actually be broken down into a few simple steps:

  • Reading online articles and reviews to figure out the right vehicle for your family’s needs
  • Taking a prospective new car out for a test drive
  • Giving it a point-by-point inspection
  • Working with a dealer to reach the most affordable price
  • Taking care of your new vehicle through maintenance and repairs

This last one may come as a surprise since, well, you just bought a new car, but despite every best intention, maintenance issues can and typically do arise.


💰💸Don’t miss this amazing Cyber Week Move! Get 60% off TheStreet Pro. Act now before it’s gone.💰💸


Instead of banging your head against the steering wheel, a smarter idea may be to gain a basic understanding of the most common car problems so you can budget and be as prepared as possible.

(Mr. Gladwell is cheering you on.)

What are the most common maintenance issues with cars?

Carfax, one of the most trusted names in the automotive industry, put together a list of the top 12 maintenance issues vehicles tend to have, as well as the estimated costs to repair them.

Related: Consumer Reports: The 10 best SUVs of 2024

This company creates detailed vehicle history reports by collecting data from insurance companies, police departments, and DMVs — and with over 31 billion vehicles analyzed over its 40-year history, you can be pretty sure it knows what it’s talking about.

Carfax’s list of common vehicle maintenance Issues

Carfax

Problem Reason Cost to repair

Car won’t start

Dead battery

$50 and up

Brake problems

Brake pads, shoes, hoses, need replacing, etc.

$300–$800

Rough engine idle

Worn-out spark plugs or other mechanical issues

$150-thousands

Leaks under car

Low engine coolant or transmission fluid

$0–1,000

Overheating

Leaky water pump or radiator, low engine oil, or cooling system issue 

$20–$10,000

Paint or finish problems

Weather damage, scratches, and dents

As much as $2,500

Stability or "tipsy" issues

Worn shocks and struts

$450–$900

Tread wear indicator

Worn tires

$300–$400 per axle

Unpredictable noises or odors

Damaged automatic transmission

$1,100–$3,000

Broken windshield

Weather or debris in road

$100–$400

Wheel alignment issues

Driving over objects or potholes

$100–$200

Check Engine light is on

Low tire pressure, fuel system, transmission problems

Varies

The great news is, most new cars come with a complimentary maintenance plan that covers basic servicing for a set time period, like 1–2 years, or a certain number of miles driven. This can include oil changes, tire rotations, multi-point inspections, and other routine maintenance tasks.

Related: Consumer Reports’ best American cars, trucks & SUVs of 2024

But what happens when the coverage period ends, or the problem you’re having doesn’t fall within its parameters?

If only car buyers had a crystal ball that could predict which vehicle models would give them the least amount of trouble over their lifetimes ...

View the original article to see embedded media.

Consumer Reports' methodology explained

Actually, they do, and it comes from the bright minds at Consumer Reports.

While some maintenance costs (like oil changes) are just plain unavoidable, there are certain car models that have been proven to experience the fewest problems over their lifespan.

Consumer Reports (CR), whose entire existence is geared toward helping consumers make informed purchase decisions, researched a decade’s worth of data to figure out the average repair and maintenance expenses for each new car on the road today (although it notes that collision repairs are not included in its estimates). 


More automotive content:


The models that topped CR’s list not only boast low repair and maintenance costs; they also score high on reliability and other factors, like fuel economy. What's more, several of these vehicles fall within the budget category, making them an even bigger win for price-conscious new car buyers.

Here are Consumer Reports' findings, categorized by car type:

The least expensive new cars to maintain by category

Nissan's 2024 Leaf earns high marks from Consumer Reports electric vehicles for its low maintenance costs.

TTTNIS, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

Electric Car: Nissan Leaf 2024

  • Price range: $28,140–$36,190
  • CR score: 57
  • Maintenance cost over a 10-year period: $2,080
The Corolla averages less than $5,000 in maintenance costs over a 10-year timeframe. 

MercurySable99, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Compact Car: Toyota Corolla 2024

  • Price range: $22,050–$28,340
  • CR score: 75
  • Maintenance cost over a 10-year period: $4,125
Toyota's Camry is another low-cost maintenance winner.

Alexander-93, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Mid-Sized Car: Toyota Camry 2024

  • Price range: $22,050–$28,340
  • CR score: 88
  • Maintenance cost over a 10-year period: $4,985
The Lexus ES Hybrid ranks high on the list of low-maintenance luxury vehicles.

Dinkun Chen, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Luxury Car: Lexus ES Hybrid 2024

  • Price range: $41,020
  • CR score: 88
  • Maintenance cost over a 10-year period: $7,920
Toyota ranks high on the list of least expensive car brands to maintain; its RAV4 averages less than $6,000 over a 10-year period.

Alexander-93, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Compact SUV: Toyota RAV4 Hybrid 2024

Price range: $28,475–$39,780
CR score: 78
Maintenance cost over a 10-year period: $5,870

The Ford Edge averaged $6,620 in maintenance costs over a decade, according to CR.

Ford

Midsized SUV: Ford Edge 2024

  • Price range: $38,465–$47,205
  • CR score: 79
  • Maintenance cost over a 10-year period: $6,620
Lexus' RX was one of two SUVs to top the Luxury category in terms of affordable maintenance.

Dinkun Chen, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Luxury SUV: Lexus RX 2024

  • Price range: $48,600–$69,230
  • CR score: 78
  • Maintenance cost over a 10-year period: $8,700
The 2024 Buick Enclave was the other luxury SUV to score high on CR's list.

HJUdall, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

Luxury SUV: Buick Enclave 2024

  • Price range: $43,900–$59,500
  • CR score: 77
  • Maintenance cost over a 10-year period: $6,610
The Mazda Miata is an affordable car to maintain. According to Consumer Reports, it averages just $2,695 in maintenance costs over a ten-year period.

HJUdall, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

Sport Car: Mazda MX-5 Miata 2024

  • Price range: $28,985–$40,210
  • CR score: 80
  • Maintenance cost over a 10-year period: $2,695

Related: The 10 best investing books (according to stock market pros)

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.