The leader of a New York City church in the Williamsburg neighborhood of Brooklyn has been relieved of his duties following an investigation that uncovered instances of mismanagement. Monsignor Jamie Gigantiello was stripped of his pastoral oversight and governance role at Our Lady of Mount Carmel – Annunciation Parish after unauthorized financial transfers were made to a former top aide in New York City Mayor Eric Adams’ administration.
Bishop Robert Brennan, of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn, appointed Bishop Witold Mroziewski as the administrator of the parish to safeguard public trust and protect church funds. Gigantiello's administrative powers were revoked after a music video shoot for Sabrina Carpenter's hit song “Feather” at the church sparked criticism last November.
The investigation also revealed that a deacon appointed as a temporary administrator used racist and offensive language during private conversations in the parish office. Gigantiello, who approved the filming of the controversial video, admitted to a lapse in judgment and expressed regret for the provocative scenes.
Further improprieties were uncovered, including Gigantiello's use of a church credit card for personal expenses and transferring parish funds to accounts affiliated with Frank Carone, Adams’ former chief of staff. Carone's law firm repaid a portion of the funds with interest, and federal investigators have subpoenaed the church for information on the financial dealings.
Gigantiello defended his actions, stating that the investments were legal and beneficial for the church. The Diocese of Brooklyn emphasized its commitment to cooperating with law enforcement in ongoing investigations.
Despite the controversy, Sabrina Carpenter humorously referenced the situation during a concert at Madison Square Garden, alluding to Mayor Adams' indictment. The church community and parishioners are now under the administration of Bishop Mroziewski as efforts are made to restore trust and sanctity within the parish.
