Less than a week after Vice President JD Vance shared the inauguration stage with a senior Catholic cardinal, a rift emerged between Vance and the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. Vance accused the bishops of resettling 'illegal immigrants' for federal funding, sparking criticism from Cardinal Timothy Dolan.
Vance invoked the concept of 'ordo amoris' to justify Trump administration's immigration policies, drawing mixed reactions from scholars and Catholic leaders. While some supported Vance's stance, others argued that Catholic teaching emphasizes helping strangers in need.
The rift reflects broader divisions within the Catholic community in Washington. The change in administrations marked a shift in Catholic power dynamics, with conservative voices gaining prominence.
Immigration is not the only issue dividing high-level Catholics. Sharp disagreements also exist over LGBTQ+ inclusion, as seen in contrasting views on recent executive orders.
Vance continues to draw on Catholic theology in his political discourse, quoting ancient theologians to support his positions on religious freedom and conscience.
The Catholic community remains divided on key social issues, highlighting the complex interplay between faith, politics, and values in Washington.
