Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Liverpool Echo
Liverpool Echo
National
Olivia Williams

Barmaid 'permanently disfigured' after woman bit her ear off in pub

A barmaid who had her ear bitten off by a woman shared shocking pictures of her injuries following the attack.

Michelle Thomas was off duty as landlady at The Firemans Arms in Birkenhead on the night of the incident. At a hearing at Liverpool Crown Court on Tuesday, Gemma Rowlands admitted wounding and was jailed for 14 months.

The court heard how Rowlands and her now husband Darren More were described as "causing trouble from the start" after entering the pub on the evening of November 11, 2019. At around 10.30pm, Rowlands began arguing with other customers and she and More were asked to leave the pub.

READ MORE: Man is sick in dock as his wife is jailed for biting pub barmaid's ear off

But a scuffle ensued in which landlady Michelle fell to the floor with Rowlands "on top of her". Her ear was bitten by the carer at this point as drinkers tried to separate them.

Michelle has now spoken out about the impact the incident has had on her, which she described as "traumatising". She has been left permanently disfigured. The 37-year-old said the pub was busy that evening due to it being Remembrance Sunday and the football being on.

She said Rowlands, More and two others came into the pub and "from the second they came in, they were making a nuisance of themselves". Michelle said as licensee and to help her staff, she thought she was best placed to deal with the situation and asked them to leave.

The incident escalated and Michelle said "all hell broke loose." Speaking to the ECHO, she said: "She went for me, they were all on top of me and there were people trying to stop it around us. Her partner was on top of me as well, the other lad that they were with was kicking me in the head.

"She bit my ear off and then we got them out of the pub and it was only then I realised that my ear [had been bitten off]. I felt her bite it, but I didn't realise she had actually bitten it off until one of customers got a cloth from behind the bar and put it on my ear.

"The police and ambulance came and from that I was taken to Arrowe Park and then taken straight over to Whiston Hospital to see if it could be reattached, but because it had been found on the floor by the paramedics, the surgeon wouldn't reattach it for me.

"He said the best option was to go down to surgery and have it all cleaned, scraped and stitched and then later on for the process of getting surgery to reconstruct my ear."

Michelle Thomas' ear after the incident in The Firemans Arms in Birkenhead (Michelle Thomas)

Michelle said her mental health has "deteriorated" following the incident and has struggled with feelings of paranoia.

She said: "I spend a lot of time at my mum's now due to my mental health, rather than staying at home. Obviously from court yesterday I went straight to my mum's and stayed there last night."

Michelle added: "For the first two years, I was really paranoid all the time. I already had OCD but my mental health deteriorated, I had all my medication increased. I then started to live it with it for a bit and then the [hearing] came around and I was back at the doctors.

"I had to come out of work while they changed all my medication again."

Michelle said she decided against surgery to reconstruct her ear due to it being extensive, meaning her ear will be permanently disfigured.

The 37-year-old said: "They made me a prosthetic one because they said it would take 12 months before I could have the reconstructive surgery. I couldn't wear it because I had to glue it on and it wasn't the same colour as my ear and it just made me feel really paranoid.

"When I went back to see the surgeon over the surgery, he explained what would take place. They would have to take cartilage from my ribs and then my ribs would have to be drained and I would have to stay in hospital on three occasions just for them to make it, for them to fix it basically.

"I had to pass a psychological evaluation, like an assessment, so I thought about it for a while and I eventually agreed to go ahead with it, but then when they sent me the form out that I had to fill in it was quite personal.

"I just broke down again and I haven't gone ahead so I am stuck like this forever."

Michelle Thomas' ear after the incident in The Firemans Arms in Birkenhead (Michelle Thomas)

Defending Rowlands at Liverpool Crown Court, who has no previous convictions, David Polglase said a dispute had erupted after his client "removed a child from the toilets" and took them to their parents, but was accused of having "scared" the youngster.

The assault then came after the 25-year-old, who works with autistic children, and her friend had been "grabbed by their hair and taken out" following the dispute.

Mr Polgase said: "She assisted in removing a child from the toilets and returned the child to one of the parents. She defended her position and said she hadn't scared the child.

"There are others involved who were not holding back or covering themselves in glory. My lay client looks back at what happened that night with remorse and regret.

"Your honour can genuinely look at this eight minutes and says that is something very different and out of character for Ms Rowlands. She has not been in trouble before.

"It is evident that my lay client can be a successful member of society and is valued in her employment. She is disgusted by her actions."

More, has one previous convictions for drink driving in 2015. After his arrest, the 31-year-old said he had consumed 12 pints of Carling and a "fight just kicked off".

He later said that he too had been acting as a "peacekeeper". Charles Lander, defending, told the court that his client worked 80 hour weeks in traffic management and had become a "step father" to Rowlands' kids.

More's counsel added: "It is over three years since the commission of this offence. Mr More isn't someone who has just sat around, he is someone who is hard-working.

"He is someone who joined the army and was hoping for a promising career, but he snapped his ligament in 2010 and his progress was cut short. References describe the defendant as hard-working, reliable, punctual, well-mannered, a joy to work with and someone who cares for his family.

"He had drunk too much that day. He was minding his own business, a man grabbed hold of him and perhaps his natural instincts kicked in at seeing his partner on the floor being restrained - he accepts what he did then became unlawful."

Rowlands, of Victoria Road in Tranmere, admitted wounding and was jailed for 14 months. More, also of Victoria Road in Tranmere, pleaded guilty to affray and was handed a four-month imprisonment suspended for a year.

Receive newsletters with the latest news, sport and what's on updates from the Liverpool ECHO by signing up here

READ NEXT:

Man is sick in dock as his wife is jailed for biting pub barmaid's ear off

Teacher who let boy, 4, leave school alone 'didn't want to be there

These are the faces of 50 Liverpool criminals who were jailed during February

Man suffers head injury after mass brawl breaks out in gym

Matalan shoppers praise 'gorgeous' £11 floral mini dress that's 'soft and comfortable'

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.