India Today anchor Shiv Aroor did a show the other day outraging that Manmohan Singh’s government had the Indian Navy bring back a colonial ensign after it was banished during Atal Bihari Vajpayee’s rule.
On 30 August, India Today's editor and anchor @ShivAroor claimed in his show #5iveLive that in 2001 Atal Bihari Vajpayee govt removed the St. George's Cross from Indian Navy flag. But, in 2004 St. George's cross was brought back on the Indian Navy flag in UPA Government. pic.twitter.com/Ps1jx80Eq5
— Abhishek (@AbhishekSay) September 15, 2022
The occasion was the navy introducing a new ensign, apparently inspired by 17th century Maratha ruler Shivaji’s royal seal, in place of St George’s Cross. The ensign was unveiled by Prime Minister Narendra Modi who said that the new flag represented an India shedding its colonial past.
Aroor’s point of outrage, implied if not explicit, was that while the BJP, from Vajpayee to Modi, cared for India’s nationalist ethos, the Congress was far removed from it.
Indeed, fellow anchors such as Sudhir Chaudhary, new face at Aaj Tak, Chitra Tripathi, old face at Aaj Tak, and Rajat Sharma of India TV, and sundry BJP talking heads made Shiv Aroor’s point more unvarnishedly: reintroducing the old ensign in 2004 showed the Congress party’s “slavish and colonial mindset”.
There was just one kink in the narrative, as an Alt News factcheck would reveal: the ensign was not reintroduced under Manmohan Singh but Vajpayee.
What’s more, the colonial ensign wasn’t brought back for any sentimental reason but a mundane practical reason. The flag – surprise! – needed to be visible in the open sea.
Aroor, in case you couldn’t tell from his show, is a “defence expert”, having founded a “defence and aerospace news site” called Livefist.
Thread
— Abhishek (@AbhishekSay) September 15, 2022
Here is how India's mainstream media and their star anchors @ShivAroor @chitraaum @sudhirchaudhary @RajatSharmaLive spread false information on the national TV and run propaganda of the ruling party BJP. (1/n)
After the Alt News factcheck, Aroor offered a non-apology apology. It remains to be seen if he issues a clarification on air where the misinformation was spread.
Regarding factcheck abt my show on Navy ensign, though story was abt latest change, I did get info WRONG on 2004 re-intro of cross. FWIW, honest mistake, no malafide, but MINE alone. Doesn’t lessen error, but made it clear navy proposed change. Will re-up in morn for visibility.
— Shiv Aroor (@ShivAroor) September 15, 2022
This is not the first time legacy media anchors have been caught propagating misinformation and anti-Muslim bigotry.
Top 12 fake news stories circulated by mainstream media in 2017
India Today shows Pakistani historian as terrorist, passes off death as grisly murder
‘Rioters’ turn ‘angry youth’, bulldozers disappear: Two sets of protests expose TV’s communal bias
Coronavirus and Nizamuddin: TV news returns to bigotry with a bang
The year that was: Misinformation trends of 2020
Postscript: Ever wonder how such “honest mistake, no malafide” falsehoods tend to go only one way? To the advantage of the BJP and at the expense of the opposition.
Update: On his evening show on Friday, Aroor said he made an error in a piece of background information and wrongly attributed the change in the Indian navy ensign to the Manmohan Singh government. Aroor said it was brought to his attention through a detailed fact-check and declared that those who projected his "honest error" as BJP propaganda were entitled to their snark, venom and abuse. "I will not brazen this off like so many in the media and politics. The error was unintended," he said.
A clarification from me on my show today. pic.twitter.com/4sIzREUA5r
— Shiv Aroor (@ShivAroor) September 16, 2022
Newslaundry is a reader-supported, ad-free, independent news outlet based out of New Delhi. Support their journalism, here.
