Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
ABC News
ABC News
National
former ABC Moscow correspondent Norman Hermant

A year at war

People walk past a sign with the words 'The Motherland we defend' in St Petersburg. (AP: Dmitri Lovetsky)

Taboo topics, a reshaped society, and lost generations: This is the new reality for Russia.

As the first anniversary of the war in Ukraine approaches and the world braces for Russia's next offensive, there's little comfort from Moscow.

In fact, Vladimir Putin may just be getting started.

His plans for a quick victory a year ago failed spectacularly. But now, Russia's president appears to be preparing for round two.

"This war is determined by Putin's own vision," Russian affairs analyst and political commentator Konstantin Eggert said.

"I don't think that anyone really knows what's happening inside the leadership.

"This is a leadership that is united by one thing: fear of Putin and fear of his secret police."

The only thing that's certain is that no-one sees through the haze obscuring the Kremlin.

A concert marked Moscow's declaration it had annexed four Russian-controlled regions of Ukraine last September. (Reuters)

In the early months of the war, there was much speculation about Mr Putin's future.

Could he be deposed in a coup? Was he seriously ill? Or might he voluntarily step down and hand power to a successor?

Now all of these topics are off limits — especially any talk of succession.

"This topic is a complete taboo in the Kremlin," said Tatiana Stanovaya, from the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

"No-one can … raise questions about it."

There's no shortage of names being bandied about if Mr Putin decides not to run for president again in 2024.

Federal Security Service director Alexander Bortnikov, Wagner mercery group head Yevgeny Prigozhin, and even Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin all get a mention.

Alexander Bortnikov, Yevgeny Prigozhin and Mikhail Mishustin are all mentioned as possible successors to Vladimir Putin. (Supplied)

Such lists are nothing more than media speculation, according to Ms Stanovaya.

"No-one knows who can be considered as a future successor," she said.

It's conceivable Mr Putin, aged 70, once thought he could spend his final years at ease, enjoying the huge fortune he's believed to have accumulated while in power.

But Ms Stanovaya believes he may now feel trapped.

Vladimir Putin chairs a Security Council meeting on February 13. (AP: Sputnik/Kremlin Pool Photo)

"There is no good scenario for Putin," she said.

"He knows that he can't be confident in anyone 100 per cent."

If the war ends badly, and he's out of power, nothing would stop a future successor from making him take the blame.

"Whoever he picks, he will face significant risks, and he knows it," Ms Stanovaya said.

As war rages on, Russian life remains insulated

Right now, Vladimir Putin also knows nothing constrains him from prosecuting the war as he sees fit.

Despite a slew of financial and trading sanctions imposed by Western countries over the past year, Russia's economy didn't grind to a halt.

From January to November 2022, oil and gas revenues actually increased by 30 per cent to $US164 billion ($239 billion).

Russia's oil and gas revenues actually increased from January to November 2022. A refinery is seen in Siberian city Omsk. (Reuters: Alexey Malgavko)

Revenue for 2023 looks set to drop significantly, but Russia still has customers for its oil.

"As long as India, China, other countries continue to buy his hydrocarbons, [Mr Putin] has money," Mr Eggert said.

"He needs the money to feed the army and supply it with whichever weaponry he can lay his hands on."

Russia's economic resiliency also insulates much of the population from the impact of war.

Dmitry, a dual Russian-Australian citizen who spent the first nine months of the war in Moscow, said the biggest noticeable change had been losing cheap, locally made cars.

"From a Russian point of view, nothing pretty much changed," he said.

Women stand next to a pond on a rainy day in Moscow. (Reuters: Evgenia Novozhenina)
Russia's economic resilience has insulated much of the population from the impact of the war.  (AP: Alexander Zemlianichenko)
Young people relax at a bar in the Siberian city of Omsk. (AP: Evgeniy Sofiychuk)
A woman walks past a street vendor in Saint Petersburg. (Reuters: Anton Vaganov)

People can still travel, but Dmitry says most of those going on holidays now head to the Middle East, or South-East Asia.

"We cannot fly easily anymore to Europe," he said.

It's more costly now for Russians to apply for visas, and a huge drop in flights since the war has seen airfares skyrocket.

"For the average person, Europe is closed," he said.

Dmitry, whose real name has been changed to protect his identity, runs a business that imports food products into Russia.

He said the brokers he dealt with in other countries were more than happy to keep trading with Russia; he had even had offers to disguise goods that should be declared under sanctions.

"The thing is what I found, in all the Middle East … they basically pull up and say, 'But what more do you want? Tell us what you want. As long as your customs is OK, we'll give it to [you].'"

Dmitry says for most Russians, everyday life has not changed very much. (Reuters: Shamil Zhumatov)

From his perspective, the war's been good for the Russian economy.

"I can tell you that a lot of businesses are profiting off of it," he said.

"A lot of factories start working 24-7 literally. A lot of employment.

"[The] construction industry is just booming."

Strategic recruitment means cities stay dormant

The economy isn't the only aspect of the war that's being misrepresented in the West, according to Dmitry.

He doesn't believe there's any problem in finding enough men willing to fight in Ukraine.

"They pay big dollars to go there [with] the army," he said.

"It's something like 300,000 roubles ($5,850) plus bonuses, which is huge money for Russia, a month."

Russian reservists march during a ceremony before their departure in Omsk. (Reuters: Alexey Malgavko)
A Russian reservist bids farewell to relatives and acquaintances during a ceremony before his departure. (Reuters: Alexey Malgavko)
Russian reservists recruited during a partial mobilisation of troops are pictured in Omsk in January. (Reuters: Alexey Malgavko)

Konstantin Eggert agrees that, for now, manpower won't be a problem for the Russian army.

It's widely rumoured a new mass mobilisation will begin soon, with a target of sending 200,000 to 500,000 more troops into battle.

But there are few signs of mass protest.

Mr Putin is careful to recruit people from outside the big cities, from places that are more isolated and have lower potential for unrest, Mr Eggert said.

"Recruitment occurs in smaller places — a small city in Russia is 200,000 or 300,000 people and less," he said.

Russian soldiers attend a service in Moscow for those involved in the war in Ukraine. (Reuters: Yulia Morozova)

"This helps Putin to replenish the reservoir of cannon fodder … without actually provoking the big population centres.

"Bearing in mind Russia's demographics, he still has probably even a few million people to throw into this meat grinder."

So, Vladimir Putin has the men and the resources to keep fighting for a long time.

And he has one more crucial element: a compliant society smothered by state security.

After thousands of arrests last year, protests against the war are now virtually non-existent.

"The majority of the Russian society is essentially dormant," Mr Eggert said.

"It withdrew itself into this kind of weird comfort zone in which there is the leadership that decides. And we just basically … watch television."

A person is detained during an anti-war protest in Yekaterinburg, March 2022. (Reuters)
A person is detained during an anti-war protest in Yekaterinburg, Russia. (Reuters)
Russian police officers detain women during an anti-war protest in St Petersburg last February. (Reuters: Anton Vaganov)
An anti-war protester wears a mask that reads "no war" during a demonstration in St Petersburg last year. (AP: Dmitri Lovetsky)

Up to a million Russians have fled the country since the start of the war.

"What Putin ensured is that this ferment is gone from the Russian system now," Mr Eggert said.

"These people [are] elsewhere, writing their Facebook posts about Putin being a bloody dictator.

"But he doesn't care about that as long as they're not inside Russia."

The heartbreak of leaving Russia

Among those who have left are Elena and Evgeny, the kind of contemporary, sophisticated professionals who were transforming Russia's big cities before the war.

Elena and Evgeny relocated to France after the war began. (Supplied)

For them, the invasion of Ukraine last February was a breaking point.

"You just feel, 'This is it,'" Elena said.

"This is the final point where you can no longer have any hopes that it will change for better, in the way that it will become a democracy."

Most of the couple's friends in Moscow were opposed to war, but as the fighting dragged on, they realised they were in the minority.

"When you start talking at work or with colleagues or with neighbours, you realise that there are people who actually support the operation, and this scares you," Elena said.

A view shows an apartment block with a mural depicting Russian President Vladimir Putin in the town of Kashira in the Moscow region. (Reuters: Evgenia Novozhenina)

"It's like there is this evil and you never knew it existed."

Like many Russians opposed to the war, they stayed away from early protests.

"It breaks you inside because you want to speak out and you're afraid," Elena said.

Concerns about the safety of their two young children also contributed to their fear of speaking out.

"[The] Russian government is really good at scaring you in a way, because they [publicise] stories that they take your children to officials to question everything," Evgeny said.

"And that's really scary."

Elena and Evgeny decided they had no choice but to leave Russia.

The letter Z (pictured in Russian city Izhevsk) has become a symbol of support for the Russian armed forces involved in the Ukraine war. (Reuters: Alexey Malgavko)
The Z symbol seen in St Petersburg last May, along with the words: "We don't abandon our people." (Reuters: Anton Vaganov)

They were lucky. Elena works for a French company that agreed to relocate the family and help with visas and accommodation.

They've slowly settled into their new lives in France. They don't see themselves returning to Russia for many years.

"We don't close the door," Elena said.

"I love the country. I really miss it.

"I'm not sure I want my kids to go back."

Australia no cure for missing Moscow

In Sydney, Anna Kharzeeva understands those contradictory feelings.

Shortly after the war started, she and her Australian husband decided to leave Russia.

While Anna's glad to be in Sydney, she hasn't stopped missing Russia. (ABC News: Brendan Esposito)

"Honestly, it was it was really hard," Ms Kharzeeva said.

"When we got [to Sydney], it was like the reality really hit. We don't have a place. We don't have a single job between the two of us.

"Our kid doesn't have child care of any sort."

Nearly a year into building a new life in Sydney, she still misses Moscow.

"I'm seeing Instagram stories of people doing stuff in Moscow in the snow or going out and going to museums," she said.

"And I'm like, 'I want to be in that street, want to be in that cafe, I want to be in that museum.'

"But at the same time, I'm aware that for me it would be incredibly hard to be there right now emotionally because I'd be like, 'There's a war that we're responsible for.'

"And when you're in Moscow, there's not a lot that you can do."

Anna Kharzeeva, who left Russia shortly after the war began, is seen at her new home in Sydney on February 10, 2023. (ABC News: Brendan Esposito)
Anna Kharzeeva, who left Russia shortly after the war began, is seen at her new home in Sydney on February 10, 2023. (ABC News: Brendan Esposito)
Anna Kharzeeva, who left Russia shortly after the war began, is seen at her new home in Sydney on February 10, 2023. (ABC News: Brendan Esposito)

Ms Kharzeeva works for a community organisation and is also continuing her career as a journalist with a focus on food and culture.

She's helped run fundraisers for Ukraine that have raised thousands of dollars.

With help from her husband's family, they've found an apartment.

Their young son has started school. And there's no shortage of people telling her how lucky she is to be in Australia.

Anna Kharzeeva, who left Russia shortly after the war began, is seen at her new home in Sydney on February 10, 2023. (ABC News: Brendan Esposito)

"Sydney people do have this tendency to think Sydney's the best," she said.

"The reality is it doesn't diminish the heartbreak. I feel like I lost my country and my identity.

"Nowhere is going to be beautiful enough to forget that you have a home you can't go to.

"I'd love for Australians to understand the beach doesn't cure everything."

Credits:

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.