Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - US
The Guardian - US
World
Hugo Lowell in Washington

A tense political moment: McCarthy laughs as ouster is decided

A middle-aged white man in a dark suit walks amid a crowd into a high ceilinged room.
Kevin McCarthy walks to the vote on the House floor to vacate his leadership in the US Capitol in Washington DC, 3 October 2023. Photograph: Jim Lo Scalzo/EPA

A grim-faced Kevin McCarthy clenched the armrest of his seat in the House chamber as he was ousted from the speakership on Tuesday, the knuckles of his right hand turning whiter with every vote that assured he would lose the gavel in a move without precedent in modern US history.

The person who had orchestrated his removal, the far-right Republican congressman Matt Gaetz, was seated about 20ft behind him, at times leaning forward in anticipation and apparent excitement.

When it was all over and the office of the House speaker was no longer his, McCarthy slumped back and laughed as several of his allies came up to shake his hand, reassuring him that he had done a good job and it wasn’t his fault, a person familiar with the matter said.

The first-ever removal of a speaker in congressional history was a tense political moment that occurred in the same way the speaker is elected – in an alphabetical roll-call vote conducted by the clerk with all the members in the chamber – with moments of high drama.

McCarthy’s ouster was the culmination of months of internal Republican party antagonism and an epic power struggle between McCarthy and a small group of hard-right members that had tormented him ever since they ultimately failed to stop his ascent to the speakership in January.

A white man with brown hair and a bright blue suit gestures with both hands as he appears to speak.
Republican congressman Matt Gaetz speaks on the floor of the US House of Representatives. Photograph: US House of Representatives/C-SPAN/Reuters

By 2pm in Washington, the upper galleries looking down onto the House chamber were packed. The press gallery, running the length of the chamber directly behind the dais, ran out of seats and a row of reporters stood against the back wall.

Down on the House floor, the anticipation among the members was focused on the upcoming vote series: the motion to table, the final chance to prevent the McCarthy removal vote from taking place, followed by the motion to vacate, the actual vote to strip McCarthy of his post.

The first vote ended up taking longer than expected. A huge number of Democrats swarmed the well of the House floor to vote by hand – holding red cards to indicate their no votes – in an effort to keep the vote open and buy time for their colleagues to get back to the Capitol.

But even with a handful of Democrats absent on Tuesday – Cori Bush, the former speaker Nancy Pelosi, Mary Peltola, Emilia Sykes – the writing on the wall was quickly becoming clear for McCarthy after nine Republicans voted to proceed to the second, removal vote.

A view down from a balcony onto a blue-carpeted room with people in it and a high, wooden dais, with a white-lettered overlay of vote tallies.
The final vote tally of 208-218 not to table the motion to oust the House speaker Kevin McCarthy. Photograph: House Television/AP

McCarthy had held out hope for some cross-party support and his aides, behind the scenes, frantically called a number of moderate Democrats to see whether they were willing to negotiate some deal in exchange for their support. There appeared to be no takers.

The atmosphere for the motion to vacate was nonetheless tense. After an hour of impassioned debate, where Gaetz was forced to speak from the Democratic side of the chamber because McCarthy allies blocked the lecterns on the Republican side, Gaetz moved seats from the front to the back.

McCarthy also changed seats and brought himself closer to the front, sitting in the aisle next to an aide. The chamber was silent – unusually quiet because the members normally chat with their seat neighbors – and most of the Republicans stood in the back, near their cloakroom.

As the clerk ticked through the roll call, there were murmurs, when the Republican Warren Davidson voted against removing McCarthy after earlier joining Democrats to proceed to the removal vote, and there were gasps, like when the Republican Nancy Mace, in a surprise move, voted to oust McCarthy.

(Standing on the east front steps of the Capitol afterwards, Mace explained that she had decided to remove McCarthy because he had not honored his agreement to her on women’s issues such as birth control access and rape kits.)

There were also moments of levity: when the far-right Republican congresswoman Lauren Boebert was called upon, she answered “not for the moment” – drawing mockery from both sides of the aisle.

A white man smiling amid a sea of people, the men dressed in suits, one woman in a white dress, and uniformed police in white uniforms with gold piping and black hats.
Kevin McCarthy walks from the House chamber after he was ousted as speaker at the US Capitol in Washington DC, on 3 October 2023. Photograph: Mandel Ngan/AFP/Getty Images

Once the number of Republicans against McCarthy climbed to seven, it was clear to McCarthy, Gaetz and everyone else, that his time was up. McCarthy put one hand over his other, palms facing upwards, and looked at the ornate stained-glass eagle on the ceiling of the chamber.

As the vote continued towards the inevitable, Gaetz looked relieved. He struck up conversations with his seat neighbors, and played with Boebert’s well-behaved baby boy who was cooing in her arms. A foot away stood the indicted Republican congressman George Santos, watching the pair interact.

By the end, when his ouster had been gavelled, a look of resignation was etched on McCarthy’s face. He sat in his seat for some time longer than others. Hours later, when he addressed the Republican conference, McCarthy told his members he would not seek another term as speaker.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.