When it comes to painting your rooms in 2025, if Pinterest is anything to go by, it seems like there is pretty much only one way to do it: drenching. And while, yes, coating your walls, trim, and ceiling in the same shade adds a certain je ne sais quoi when it comes to color, is there ever a time when doing so is a bad idea? Absolutely.
Layouts and lighting schemes have a huge influence on the way bold paint colors interact in a space. Sometimes painting in a monochromatic palette translates as cozy and chic, but other times it can end up feeling completely overwhelming. And depending on the style of your home, sometimes designers err against ever painting your ceiling and walls the same color.
So to drench or not to drench? I put the question to interior designers, and they identified the four instances below, when you should steer clear of the matching method.
1. When You Want to Make a Statement of Your 'Fifth Wall'
While color drenching certainly has a refined appeal, when it comes to the ways we're using color in our spaces lately, there is another approach that's been gaining traction, and it's not so conducive to a one-tone palette. It's making a statement of our ceiling (or the 'fifth wall') — arguably the new way to do an 'accent wall'.
"It's a brand-new surface, sprung as if from nowhere, just when we thought we’d counted them all," says Livingetc's color expert, Amy Moorea Wong. Choosing a monochromatic color scheme means you lose a big opportunity to accentuate your room's uniqueness. Looking for a modern living room idea that shows off your favorite colors and aesthetics? Using your ceiling means a "20 percent increase of the wall space you previously had to do what you want with, and that sounds like a too-good-to-waste opportunity to me" adds Amy.
2. When You're Working With a Room With Low Light
Dramatic color palettes are one of the biggest interior design trends of the moment. Something about an oxblood red or deep forest green instantly transforms a room into an elegant living space.
But, a moody palette can quickly become constricting when not executed properly. "It’s best to avoid paint-matching with dark hues on walls and ceilings in rooms that receive little to no natural light," says Washington, D.C.-based interior designer Elana Mendelson. "If a room already feels too dark, drenching it in a dark color as well could make it feel more like a cave than cozy."
This doesn't mean you have to completely ditch your deep and dark dreams altogether, though. To brighten a dark room with paint, try a shade on the ceiling that's just a shade or two lighter than the walls. This will create dimension and will once again, make the ceilings feel taller and less confining.
Alternatively, if you want to embrace the cozy, cocooning feel in your dark room, a double-drenching paint technique might help appease the unwanted confining effect. That way the different colors you choose for your walls and ceiling are repeated around the room. Georgina Wilson, founder and principal architect at Georgina Wilson Associates, says, "a less-used space like a library, office, or study with a cozy vibe, this is where I’d suggest doing this."
3. When You're Painting an Open-Concept Room
When attempting to color-drench an open-concept floor plan, where do you start and where do you stop? But furthermore, it's unlikely you're going to achieve the technique's signature enveloping feel in a wide open space, and instead, run the risk of the room feeling flat and one-dimensional.
"There are practical ways to cope with the room’s size, layout, and orientation, so don’t feel penned in," says Amy Moorea Wong. Painting the ceiling a slight darker color than white (something like a dusty pink, light blue, or a soft tan) can help bring the room in slightly and make your open concept feel cozy.
Choosing different colors for your ceilings and walls also help you "create character by zoning some of the elements within the open plan," adds paint color expert and Farrow & Ball brand ambassador, Patrick O'Donnell.
4. When the Room Has Architectural Details
Having a home with gorgeous crown molding is a modern-day luxury, and the details should be celebrated instead of hidden or left unnoticeable. "When a room has great architectural details — like crown molding or beams — you want those to pop, not disappear into a single color," explains interior designer Jodi Peterman, of Elizabeth Erin Designs. In past incarnations of drenching with color, matching trim to walls and ceilings is something we saw a lot of — but in hindsight, this can actually read a little flat.
"As I always tell my clients, 'contrast is what gives a space depth'," she adds. "When everything is one color, you risk losing the dimension that makes a room feel dynamic and intentional."
But that's not to say your ceiling and trim need to be different colors. A good rule of thumb here is to think about which aspect of the room you want to highlight, and go from there.
As always, there is a time and place for everything. "I’m not saying we all need pistachio-colored ceilings next to peach walls or a cerulean and cherry combo," says Amy, but "let’s start entertaining the idea of something other than white up there, and that there is another option if you decide you’re over color drenching."
