Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Tom’s Guide
Tom’s Guide
Technology
Rory Mellon

I’ve seen every Oscar movie — here’s the 5 you need to watch

Dominic Sessa and Paul Giamatti in The Holdovers .

Each year I make it my mission to watch every single movie nominated for an Academy Award in the eight major categories (Picture, directing, acting and screenplay). And now that I’ve checked off all the biggest Oscars movies of 2024, I can confirm that it’s a very strong field this year. 

You could watch all 10 nominees in the Best Picture category, and you wouldn’t find a bad movie in the bunch. But if you’re a little short on time, and only want to watch the real cream of the crop, then I’m rounding up my top 5 favorite picks down below. 

From a courtroom drama that had me so close to the edge of my seat that I was in danger of falling to the floor, to a heartfelt comedy-drama that’s the cinematic equivalent of a warm hug. This year’s Oscar movies are of the highest quality, here’s the 5 you should watch first. 

‘Anatomy of a Fall’ 

Much to my disappointment, "Anatomy of a Fall"  looks set to walk away from Oscar night empty-handed. This French courtroom drama is nominated in five categories, including Best Picture and Best Director (for Justine Trent), but it faces stiff competition in all of them. At least it’s already got a major trophy to its name having won the prestigious Palme d’Or at last year’s 76th Cannes Film Festival. 

One of the most engrossing movies of 2023, "Anatomy of a Fall" follows a successful novelist (Sandra Hüller) who is accused of murdering her husband (Samuel Theis) by pushing him out of a third-story window. While she protests her innocence, her blind son (Milo Machado-Graner) is caught in the middle as the sole witness to the events. Hüller gives a true acting masterclass in the lead role, but the performances across the board are stellar. Plus, the twisting plot will keep you hooked up until the end. 

‘The Holdovers’ 

By the time the credits rolled on "The Holdovers" my jaw was starting to ache from smiling too much. They don’t make movies like this anymore, but Alexander Payne’s holiday-themed comedy is a testament to the enduring appeal of an unashamedly heartfelt movie. This delightful film will have you laughing one moment and tearing up the next, and you might just declare it your new favorite movie by the end. 

"The Holdout" sees Paul Giamatti give the best performance of his career, as Paul Hunham, a cranky professor at a posh New England boarding school. Forced to stay on campus over Christmas break to look after the students with nowhere else to go, the inflexible educator develops an unexpected bond with a young burnout (Dominic Sessa) and the school’s cook (Da’Vin Joy Randolph) who’s still grieving the death of her son. This odd trio are unlikely companions, but over the festive period, their bond grows in ways that will warm your soul. 

Buy/rent on Amazon or Apple

‘Oppenheimer’ 

"Oppenheimer" has dominated the awards shows that precede the Oscars, and the narrative is building that this year is Nolan’s overdue time in the spotlight. So, if "Oppenheimer" does prove to be the movie that finally wins the British filmmaker Best Picture (and almost certainly Best Director), then there really couldn’t have been a more deserving flick. 

Recounting the life of Robert J. Oppenheimer and the Manhattan Project that birthed the first atomic bomb, this biopic packs just about everything you could want from a movie. For starters, the stacked cast list all give career-best performances, none more so than Cillian Murphy in the lead role, while the direction from Nolan is masterful with inventive touches such as the sequence depicting Oppenheimer’s post-bomb-dropping speech. Plus, this is a three-hour movie that speeds by in a flash. In a seriously strong year for movies "Oppenheimer" would be a worthy winner, and it’s no wonder it’s the current favorite to win. 

Buy/rent on Amazon or Apple

'Past Lives’ 

I’m pretty happy with the Oscar nominations this year, but there was one snub that broke my heart: Greta Lee not getting a Best Actress nod for her powerful performance in "Past Lives." Lee plays Nora Moon, a South Korean immigrant who moved to Canada as a child, and she anchors this stunningly beautiful drama. 

A semi-autobiographical debut from director Celine Song, "Past Lives" chronicles the shifting dynamic between two childhood friends, Nora and Hae (Teo Yoo), over more than two decades, as they grow apart, come back together and reflect on the choices they’ve made (and didn’t make) over a fateful week. What could have been a cheap “will they, won’t they” narrative is elevated by Song’s impressively tender screenplay and two wonderfully subtle performances from its leads. The whole movie is utterly enchanting, but it’s the melancholic ending that leaves the biggest mark. 

Rent/buy on Amazon or Apple

‘Poor Things’ 

"Poor Things" is a fiendishly funny comedy with a wickedly wonderful leading turn from Emma Stone as Bella Baxter, a young woman brought back to life by a kooky scientist (Willem Dafoe) who embarks on an adventure of self-discovery with a debauched lawyer (Mark Ruffalo) at her side. Along the way, she discovers about herself and also learns about the wider world around her. 

A quick word of warning, "Poor Things" is not a movie to watch with your parents — there’s a whole load of risque material here — but if you don’t mind a few smutty scenes, it’s easily the funniest movie of 2023. The core cast clearly had a ball making this movie, and director Yorgos Lanthimos brings that aspect to the screen in spades. Only a slightly rushed third act dents "Poor Things" because otherwise, it's probably the most consistently entertaining pick on this list. 

More from Tom's Guide

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.