Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Sydney Morning Herald
The Sydney Morning Herald
Comment
James Massola

While Indonesia burns, the people want to know Jokowi is listening

Jakarta: On October 20, Indonesian President Joko Widodo will finally be sworn in and begin his second and final term in office, six months after winning re-election.

"I have nothing to lose," he recently declared, promising much-needed reforms including corporate tax cuts, an easing of strict employment laws and measures to lift foreign investment.

But since being re-elected the President has made a series of missteps and ill-advised decisions that have invited questions about his judgement.

Most obvious is his decision to create a new national capital city on the island of Borneo, in East Kalimantan province, a $48.4 billion non-solution to one of the country's most intractable problems: Jakarta.

Pollution in the capital has been so bad in recent months that it has had some of the worst air quality scores in the world.

While the city's citizens are warm, welcoming and good-humoured, Jakarta is over-crowded, traffic-choked and incredibly vulnerable to climate change. Parts of northern Jakarta are sinking by as much as 25 centimetres each year.

But moving the capital is not the solution. Shifting two million citizens, when greater Jakarta is home to 30 million people, will hardly make a dent. Budget blow outs are inevitable, thousands of hectares of virgin forests will be destroyed and it's debatable whether the country can afford it.

A massive power failure in August across much of the main island of Java left 50 million people without power for hours. Joko wagged his finger at PLN, the state power company, but not much has been done to reform the country's creaking state-owned enterprises.

In the last month, civil society groups have been up in arms over laws that will weaken the country's much-respected anti-corruption commission (the KPK) and sweeping, draconian revisions to the penal code which would make sex and cohabitation outside marriage, spreading communist ideology and insulting the president illegal (to name but a few changes) have been advanced.

The KPK law changes are particularly egregious and were rushed through the current Parliament in its last three weeks.

It's hardly a coincidence that corrupt politicians, a regular target for the KPK, want to hobble the body.

Amid mounting public pressure and protests, Joko caved in and asked Parliament to halt its rush to pass the revised criminal code last Friday. Tens of thousands of people have stayed on the streets to protest, however.

It now looks like the President, widely known as Jokowi, could cave in again and issue a perppu (directive) to block the legal changes to the KPK - which he had already waved through - thus sacrificing more political capital.

That it has taken the President so long to (possibly) arrive at such an obvious course of action suggests he hasn't been paying attention, has been badly briefed, or is beholden to a Parliament that could block his second term agenda.

While discontent has grown, huge forest fires have swept through Kalimantan and Sumatra, blanketing parts of Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore in thick smoke.

Meanwhile Papua burns, with dozens of people killed in deadly riots over the last month in the restive provinces.

Joko, to his credit, has actually visited Papua and West Papua several times and had infrastructure built. But the riots indicate his "peace through investment" approach has had limited success.

And this is just in the last few months.

Back in January, there was an outcry and humiliating backflip over the early release of radical Islamic cleric Abu Bakar Bashir, the spiritual leader of Jemaah Islamiah, the group that carried out the 2002 Bali bombing.

The President has not kept his first term promise to resolve human rights violations dating back to the communist purges of the mid-1960s and the post-Soeharto 1998 riots.

He has pandered to Islamists at times and dropped his former ally Ahok - the ethnically-Chinese, Christian former governor of Jakarta - like a hot potato when he was put on trial and convicted of blasphemy.

The deadly riots following the official declaration of his election victory in May and the heavy-handed police response - Amnesty International says protesters were tortured - have led to no significant sanctions.

Progress on opening the economy to much-needed foreign investment in his first term has been limited.

The President has delivered major investment in infrastructure in his first five years, from new air and seaports, highways and (finally) an underground metro rail in Jakarta. But his focus on the economy has arguably been too narrow, and he frequently steps in to solve broader problems only at the last minute.

Of course no one person can "fix" a country or be reasonably held responsible for all its ills.

But Joko - who is not of the political, economic and military establishment that has run this country for decades - is a symbol of hope for tens of millions of Indonesians.

And before his second term has even begun, he has done severe political damage to himself and disappointed tens of millions.

A friend suggests two words to describe Joko. One is bebal.

"It means you tell someone something over and over but he does not listen."

The other is ndableg, an old Javanese word which means stubborn.

Indonesia deserves a president who is a little less stubborn and who listens to the people a little more - not the vested interests who have run this country for decades.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.